Illegal attack or legitimate target? Israel attacks Al Manar
Arab Media & Society · 2007
DOI: 10.70090/ae07ialt ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Arab Media & Society, 2007. Verfasst von ANdrew Exum.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
“The bombing of Al Manar is a clear demonstration that Israel has a policy of using violence to silence media it doesn’t agree with. This action means media can become routine targets in every conflict. It is a strategy that spells catastrophe for press freedom and should never be endorsed by a government that calls itself democratic.” - Aidan White, General Secretary, International Federation of Journalists Among the many targets hit by Israel during the Israel-Hizbullah conflict were the headquarters of Al Manar, Hizbullah’s satellite television station (for the full story see Paul Cochrane). Also destroyed were relay stations in northern Lebanon used to broadcast two other Lebanese television stations, LBC and Al Mustaqbal. An Israeli military official later explained the second attack—which killed one LBC employee—reasoning that LBC may have been sharing relay facilities with Al Manar. These attacks were not surprising to most commentators on the war. While the bombing of the LBC and Al Mustaqbal facilities on Mount Terboul may have shocked some, few if any expected Al Manar, located in the heart of Beirut’s southern suburbs, to emerge from the conflict unscathed. Indeed, as some predicted, Al Manar’s central headquarters in southern Beirut were one of the first targets hit by Israel. The central question raised by these attacks on media outlets is when, if ever, is it appropriate and/or legal to deliberately target the media as part of a military campaign? Did Al Manar constitute a legitimate military target? Or did Israel cross the line in targeting a media outlet? What, exactly, constitutes a “legitimate” military target? And are critics of Israel’s strike against Al Manar correct when they allege that Israel’s actions against Al Manar create such a precedent that it endangers all media?
Zitieren
APA
Exum, A. (2007). Illegal attack or legitimate target? Israel attacks Al Manar. Arab Media & Society. https://doi.org/10.70090/ae07ialt
Vancouver
Exum A. Illegal attack or legitimate target? Israel attacks Al Manar. Arab Media & Society. 2007. doi:10.70090/ae07ialt
BibTeX
@article{Exum2007,
author = {Exum, ANdrew},
title = {Illegal attack or legitimate target? Israel attacks Al Manar},
journal = {Arab Media & Society},
year = {2007},
doi = {10.70090/ae07ialt}
}
EUVIMED