Comparative Assessment of Monte Carlo Simulation and MGAU Software for Non–Destructive Assay of Enriched Uranium Fuel Materials
Science of Alloys and Glasses · 01.06.2025 · 02 (1) · 86-96
DOI: 10.69626/sag.2025.0086 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Science of Alloys and Glasses, online erschienen am 01.06.2025. Verfasst von Sayed A. Makhlouf Makhlouf und 1 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The verification of nuclear materials remains a fundamental pillar of international safeguards agreements, requiring accurate and non-destructive measurement techniques that can be deployed under varying inspection conditions. This study presents a comprehensive evaluation of two distinct approaches for determining the 235U mass content in uranium oxide fuel rods: the Monte Carlo N-Particle (MCNP5) simulation method and the commercially available MGAU gamma spectrum analysis software. Both methods rely on the passive measurement of gamma radiation emitted from nuclear material, specifically focusing on the 185.7 keV gamma ray signature associated with the decay of 235U. Using a high-purity germanium detector, measurements were conducted at three different source-to-detector distances to assess the robustness and reliability of each verification technique under realistic inspection scenarios. The Monte Carlo approach involved calculating key parameters affecting measurement accuracy, including absolute full-energy peak efficiency and fractional solid angle, followed by estimating 235U mass through comparison with measured count rates. The MGAU method provided direct enrichment values from spectral analysis, which were then used to derive isotopic mass based on known total uranium content. Results demonstrated that the MCNP5 method yielded relative accuracies of 2.213, 0.891, and -3.909 percent with corresponding relative precisions of 2.732, 2.748, and 2.187 percent for measurement distances of 23.7, 17.75, and 11 centimeters, respectively. In comparison, the MGAU approach produced relative accuracies of 3.784, -1.042, and -2.917 percent with substantially larger relative precisions of 10.538, 10.034, and 6.275 percent across the same distances. The increased uncertainty observed with MGAU was attributed primarily to relatively short measurement acquisition times, while the Monte Carlo method showed sensitivity to precise distance determination. Overall, the Monte Carlo simulation approach demonstrated superior consistency with declared values and better alignment with the practical constraints encountered by inspectors during field verification activities.
Zitieren
APA
Makhlouf, S. A. M., & El-Taher, A. (2025). Comparative Assessment of Monte Carlo Simulation and MGAU Software for Non–Destructive Assay of Enriched Uranium Fuel Materials. Science of Alloys and Glasses, 02(1), 86-96. https://doi.org/10.69626/sag.2025.0086
Vancouver
Makhlouf SAM, El-Taher A. Comparative Assessment of Monte Carlo Simulation and MGAU Software for Non–Destructive Assay of Enriched Uranium Fuel Materials. Science of Alloys and Glasses. 2025;02(1):86-96. doi:10.69626/sag.2025.0086
BibTeX
@article{Makhlouf2025,
author = {Makhlouf, Sayed A. Makhlouf and El-Taher, Atef},
title = {Comparative Assessment of Monte Carlo Simulation and MGAU Software for Non–Destructive Assay of Enriched Uranium Fuel Materials},
journal = {Science of Alloys and Glasses},
year = {2025},
volume = {02},
number = {1},
pages = {86--96},
doi = {10.69626/sag.2025.0086}
}
EUVIMED