A Comparative Evaluation of Classical Structural Analysis Methods and the Matrix Stiffness Method for Beams and Frames Considering Axial Effects
Kabul Polytechnic University International Journal of Engineering & Technology · 07.11.2026 · 6 (2) · 113-124
DOI: 10.68924/mtg27976 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Kabul Polytechnic University International Journal of Engineering & Technology, online erschienen am 07.11.2026. Verfasst von Mohammad Masoud Masoomi.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This study addresses the influence of axial stiffness assumptions on the results obtained by different methods of structural analysis and its implications on the education of structural analysis. Students frequently use structural analysis software such as ETABS without fully understanding the analytical procedures implemented by the software. To address this issue, a continuous beam and a sidesway portal frame were analyzed using the Slope-Deflection Method, Moment Distribution Method, Kani’s Method, Matrix Stiffness Method, and ETABS. For the purpose of controlled evaluation, the cross-sectional area of the frame members was reduced while the bending stiffness (EI) was maintained constant. Results showed identical outcomes for all methods for the continuous beam in both configurations, demonstrating that its response was mainly controlled by flexural behavior. However, different behavior was observed in the portal frame. The three classical methods (SDM, MDM, and Kani’s Method) showed no change in the results because axial deformation effects are not explicitly included in their formulations, whereas the Matrix Stiffness Method and ETABS produced noticeable changes due to the inclusion of axial stiffness effects. The results highlight the significance of stiffness-based formulations in the capturing of structural behavior, and show how the knowledge of the Matrix Stiffness Method can help students in understanding results obtained from software. The study also emphasizes the importance of giving more attention to the stiffness-based analysis methods in structural analysis education while maintaining the educational value of the traditional hand-calculation methods.
Zitieren
APA
Masoomi, M. M. (2026). A Comparative Evaluation of Classical Structural Analysis Methods and the Matrix Stiffness Method for Beams and Frames Considering Axial Effects. Kabul Polytechnic University International Journal of Engineering & Technology, 6(2), 113-124. https://doi.org/10.68924/mtg27976
Vancouver
Masoomi MM. A Comparative Evaluation of Classical Structural Analysis Methods and the Matrix Stiffness Method for Beams and Frames Considering Axial Effects. Kabul Polytechnic University International Journal of Engineering & Technology. 2026;6(2):113-124. doi:10.68924/mtg27976
BibTeX
@article{Masoomi2026,
author = {Masoomi, Mohammad Masoud},
title = {A Comparative Evaluation of Classical Structural Analysis Methods and the Matrix Stiffness Method for Beams and Frames Considering Axial Effects},
journal = {Kabul Polytechnic University International Journal of Engineering & Technology},
year = {2026},
volume = {6},
number = {2},
pages = {113--124},
doi = {10.68924/mtg27976}
}
EUVIMED