Computation Without Users: A Brief Commentary on The Physical Signature of Computation
MetaScientia: Journal of the History and Philosophy of Science · 2026
DOI: 10.68469/n2fw5250 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift MetaScientia: Journal of the History and Philosophy of Science, 2026. Verfasst von Jorge Ignacio Fuentes. Die Arbeit nennt 14 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
I comment on key passages of Anderson and Piccinini’s The Physical Signature of Computation: Firstly, on the conditions for a mapping to be weak, robust, or strong. In doing so, I focus on the motivation for the physical-computational equivalence (PCE) condition regarding Putnam-like arguments for unlimited pancomputationalism. Secondly, on the relationship between the robust mapping account and the mechanistic account of physical computation. Here, I emphasize that the former allows computation to be ascribed regardless of user existence, based solely on the intrinsic physical properties of the computing systems. Thirdly, on the three self-simulation arguments for causal limited pancomputationalism that the book tackles. Finally, I propose two points that I think remain open for further philosophical inquiry on the Chapter on Computation and the Mind: (a) how the ought in teleological functions relates to other sorts of oughts. I claim this is an important issue for the philosophy of psychiatry, as the descriptive element of mental disorders, viz., dysfunction, is usually described as non-normative; and (b) the kind of physical quality that might be relevant to describe phenomenal experience. I claim that examples such as shape and mass are only limitedly enlightening in this regard, and that further elucidation is needed for consciousness qualitativism.
Zitieren
APA
Fuentes, J. I. (2026). Computation Without Users: A Brief Commentary on The Physical Signature of Computation. MetaScientia: Journal of the History and Philosophy of Science. https://doi.org/10.68469/n2fw5250
Vancouver
Fuentes JI. Computation Without Users: A Brief Commentary on The Physical Signature of Computation. MetaScientia: Journal of the History and Philosophy of Science. 2026. doi:10.68469/n2fw5250
BibTeX
@article{Fuentes2026,
author = {Fuentes, Jorge Ignacio},
title = {Computation Without Users: A Brief Commentary on The Physical Signature of Computation},
journal = {MetaScientia: Journal of the History and Philosophy of Science},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.68469/n2fw5250}
}
EUVIMED