EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Open Access · CC BY 4.0

TRAINING QUALITY AND ITS ROLE IN PEDAGOGICAL AND TECHNOLOGICAL GAINS AMONG SCHOOL TEACHERS IN PUNJAB

Sara Sajjad, Dr. Muhammad Arshad

Insights (Bhalwal) International Journal of Humanities, Management, and Social Sciences · 30.08.2026 · 3 (6) · 26-38

DOI: 10.68156/sy38y253 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Insights (Bhalwal) International Journal of Humanities, Management, and Social Sciences, online erschienen am 30.08.2026. Verfasst von Sara Sajjad und 1 weiteren Autor:innen. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Large-scale in-service training is the main instrument through which Pakistan’s provincial governments attempt to improve teaching in public schools, yet evaluations rarely examine which features of training quality translate into changes in teachers’ practice. Drawing on Kirkpatrick’s evaluation model, Guskey’s professional development evaluation framework, and the core-features model of effective professional development, this study tested an input–process–outcome model in which resource adequacy, trainer competency, and content relevance predict two outcomes: pedagogical skill development and technology integration. Survey data were collected from public school teachers in Punjab through multistage random sampling; after removal of duplicate and invariant records, 330 complete responses were analysed. Confirmatory factor analysis supported a five-factor measurement model (CFI = .921, TLI = .912, RMSEA = .058, SRMR = .051). Structural equation modelling, with a composite-based path analysis as a robustness check, showed that content relevance was the strongest predictor of trainer competency (β = .84), and that trainer competency and content relevance jointly explained most of the variance in pedagogical skill development (R² = .68). Trainer competency was the strongest predictor of technology integration (β = .45; R² = .41), whereas resource adequacy had small and largely indirect effects. Trainer competency mediated the effect of content relevance on technology integration. The findings indicate that the quality of training content and of the trainers who deliver it, rather than logistical provision alone, accounts for most of the variation in teachers’ perceived training gains. Training providers should treat trainer preparation, needs-based content, and adequate resourcing as interdependent levers of training effectiveness rather than as administrative inputs. In Pakistan, provincial governments rely on large-scale in-service training in trying to improve learning in their public schools, but relatively few evaluations study multiple dimensions of training quality to lead to particular changes in teacher practice. Drawing on Kirkpatrick's evaluation model, Guskey's professional development evaluation framework, and the core-features model of effective professional development, we test an input-process-outcome model where resource adequacy, trainer competency, and content relevance predict the two outcome variables of pedagogical skill and technology integration. Data were collected from public school teachers in Punjab via a multistage random sampling survey; 330 valid responses were analyzed after removing duplicates and invariant records. A five-factor measurement model was confirmed (CFI = .921; TLI = .912; RMSEA = .058; SRMR = .051). Structural equation modeling and composite-based robustness checks indicated that content relevance was the strongest predictor of trainer competency (β = .84) and that trainer competency and content relevance explained the majority of the variance in pedagogical skill development (R² = .68). Technology integration's strongest predictor was trainer competency (β =.45; R² =.41), while resource adequacy had small and mostly indirect effects. The effect of content relevance on technology integration was mediated by trainer competency. Our findings suggest that it is the quality of content and trainers rather than logistical provision that accounts for much of the variance in teachers' perceived gains from training. Training providers should therefore view trainer preparation, needs-based content, and adequate resourcing as levers of training effectiveness rather than as administrative inputs.

Zitieren

APA

Sajjad, S., & Arshad, D. M. (2026). TRAINING QUALITY AND ITS ROLE IN PEDAGOGICAL AND TECHNOLOGICAL GAINS AMONG SCHOOL TEACHERS IN PUNJAB. Insights (Bhalwal) International Journal of Humanities, Management, and Social Sciences, 3(6), 26-38. https://doi.org/10.68156/sy38y253

Vancouver

Sajjad S, Arshad DM. TRAINING QUALITY AND ITS ROLE IN PEDAGOGICAL AND TECHNOLOGICAL GAINS AMONG SCHOOL TEACHERS IN PUNJAB. Insights (Bhalwal) International Journal of Humanities, Management, and Social Sciences. 2026;3(6):26-38. doi:10.68156/sy38y253

BibTeX
@article{Sajjad2026,
  author = {Sajjad, Sara and Arshad, Dr. Muhammad},
  title = {TRAINING QUALITY AND ITS ROLE IN PEDAGOGICAL AND TECHNOLOGICAL GAINS AMONG SCHOOL TEACHERS IN PUNJAB},
  journal = {Insights (Bhalwal) International Journal of Humanities, Management, and Social Sciences},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {3},
  number = {6},
  pages = {26--38},
  doi = {10.68156/sy38y253}
}
Kostenlos starten →