The Same Scar in Different Flesh
Truth in Research · 07.07.2026 · 1 (1)
DOI: 10.67690/brwjge48 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Truth in Research, online erschienen am 07.07.2026. Verfasst von Matt Nailor und 1 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The broken vitamin C gene, GULO, is among the most frequently cited examples of shared genetic error said to prove common descent. The argument holds that humans and other primates carry the same disabled gene because they inherited it from a single common ancestor in which it first broke. I examine four lines of evidence and argue that the pattern is better explained by recurrent, independent degradation of a fragile gene across separately created kinds. First, GULO has been lost independently in many unrelated groups, including anthropoid primates, guinea pigs, lagomorphs, bats, and passerine birds, with different exons affected in each, a signature of repeated parallel loss rather than single inheritance. Second, in the two lineages everyone agrees lost GULO independently, humans and guinea pigs, over half of the substitutions are identical, a coincidence so extreme that even researchers committed to common descent invoked mutational hotspots to explain it, calculating the probability of chance at 1.83 times ten to the negative twelfth. Third, the recent claim that a shared chromosome 8 inversion confirms common GULO evolution fails on its own data: the authors' statistical test did not support an association between the inversion and pseudogenization, the inversion length was variable rather than breakpoint identical, and the locus sits within a roughly two million base pair rearrangement prone zone. Fourth, the human and Neanderthal GULO pseudogenes differ by only four single nucleotide variants across the conserved exons, a shared broken state that is exactly what my model predicts, since Neanderthals are human. Taken together, the GULO data favor a model of common design followed by independent degradation, not common descent.
Zitieren
APA
Nailor, M., & Budinsky, D. (2026). The Same Scar in Different Flesh. Truth in Research, 1(1). https://doi.org/10.67690/brwjge48
Vancouver
Nailor M, Budinsky D. The Same Scar in Different Flesh. Truth in Research. 2026;1(1). doi:10.67690/brwjge48
BibTeX
@article{Nailor2026,
author = {Nailor, Matt and Budinsky, Donny},
title = {The Same Scar in Different Flesh},
journal = {Truth in Research},
year = {2026},
volume = {1},
number = {1},
doi = {10.67690/brwjge48}
}
EUVIMED