When Answers Come Before Questions: Does Generative Artificial Intelligence Weaken Students’ Independent Thinking?
Journal of Psychology & Education · 31.10.2026 · 1 (9) · 41-58
DOI: 10.66581/4gskcp89 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Psychology & Education, online erschienen am 31.10.2026. Verfasst von Xia Lang. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The rapid adoption of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) in education has renewed a fundamental question: does convenient access to machine-generated explanations, arguments, and solutions weaken students’ willingness and capacity to think independently? The question cannot be answered by treating AI use as a single behavior or equating fluent academic products with genuine learning. This conceptual and argumentative article examines the conditions under which GenAI may displace, rather than support, essential cognitive activity. Drawing on cognitive offloading, self-regulated learning, cognitive load theory, the ICAP framework, and emerging experimental and review evidence, it distinguishes immediate task performance from durable competence and behavioral compliance from intellectual agency. Three risks are emphasized: premature delegation of problem formulation and reasoning, uncritical acceptance of plausible outputs, and reduced practice in monitoring and correcting one’s own understanding. Equally, structured AI tutoring, dialogic challenge, formative feedback, and accessibility support can extend opportunities for deeper learning. The article proposes a pedagogical principle of protected cognitive agency: students should retain responsibility for defining questions, constructing initial explanations, evaluating evidence, and demonstrating independent transfer, even when AI assists with peripheral operations. A four-phase instructional sequence—attempt, consult, contest, and reconstruct—is offered as a practical heuristic rather than an empirically validated intervention. Implications for assessment, teacher practice, equity, and longitudinal research are discussed. The central conclusion is conditional: GenAI does not inevitably diminish independent thinking, but educational systems can create that outcome when they reward polished answers without protecting the mental work through which understanding is formed.
Zitieren
APA
Lang, X. (2026). When Answers Come Before Questions: Does Generative Artificial Intelligence Weaken Students’ Independent Thinking?. Journal of Psychology & Education, 1(9), 41-58. https://doi.org/10.66581/4gskcp89
Vancouver
Lang X. When Answers Come Before Questions: Does Generative Artificial Intelligence Weaken Students’ Independent Thinking?. Journal of Psychology & Education. 2026;1(9):41-58. doi:10.66581/4gskcp89
BibTeX
@article{Lang2026,
author = {Lang, Xia},
title = {When Answers Come Before Questions: Does Generative Artificial Intelligence Weaken Students’ Independent Thinking?},
journal = {Journal of Psychology & Education},
year = {2026},
volume = {1},
number = {9},
pages = {41--58},
doi = {10.66581/4gskcp89}
}
EUVIMED