Settlement of Customary and Islamic Inheritance Disputes in Indonesia: Analysis of Choice of Law and the Authority of Religious Courts and General Courts
Selaparang: Journal of Law Studies · 18.10.2020 · 1 (2)
DOI: 10.66277/sejals.1.2.76 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Selaparang: Journal of Law Studies, online erschienen am 18.10.2020. Verfasst von Inayatul Mutmainnah und 4 weiteren Autor:innen. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Inheritance legal pluralism in Indonesia presents complex jurisdictional overlaps between Customary Law (Hukum Adat), Islamic Law (Faraidh), and Western Civil Law (BW). This study critically examines the resolution of inheritance disputes involving Muslim heirs who navigate between Customary Law and Islamic Law within the dual court jurisdictions of Religious Courts (Peradilan Agama) and District Courts (Peradilan Negeri). Utilizing a normative and empirical legal research methodology incorporating statutory analysis, choice of law doctrine (choice of law/pilihan hukum), and judicial case reviews, the findings demonstrate that Law No. 3 of 2006 effectively eliminated the choice of law option for Muslim litigants, granting absolute jurisdiction over inheritance matters to Religious Courts. However, sociological realities reveal that many local Muslim communities continue to settle inheritance distribution through customary consensus (musyawarah adat) utilizing peace agreements (sulh). The study illustrates that harmonizing Islamic inheritance law (faraidh) with customary equitable distribution mechanisms under the umbrella of takharuj (voluntary waiver of share) successfully bridges formal legal mandates with socio-cultural fairness.Pluralisme hukum waris di Indonesia menghadirkan tumpang tindih yurisdiksi yang kompleks antara Hukum Adat, Hukum Islam (Faraidh), dan Hukum Perdata Barat (BW). Studi ini mengkaji secara kritis penyelesaian sengketa waris yang melibatkan ahli waris Muslim—yang berada di antara Hukum Adat dan Hukum Islam—dalam sistem peradilan ganda, yakni Peradilan Agama dan Peradilan Negeri. Dengan menggunakan metodologi penelitian hukum normatif dan empiris yang mencakup analisis peraturan perundang-undangan, doktrin pilihan hukum (choice of law), serta tinjauan atas putusan pengadilan, studi ini menunjukkan bahwa Undang-Undang Nomor 3 Tahun 2006 telah menghapus opsi pilihan hukum bagi pihak yang beragama Islam, dengan memberikan yurisdiksi mutlak atas perkara waris kepada Peradilan Agama. Namun, realitas sosiologis menunjukkan bahwa banyak komunitas Muslim setempat tetap menyelesaikan pembagian warisan melalui konsensus adat (musyawarah adat) dengan memanfaatkan kesepakatan damai (sulh). Studi ini menggambarkan bahwa penyelarasan hukum waris Islam (faraidh) dengan mekanisme pembagian yang adil menurut adat—di bawah konsep takharuj (pelepasan hak waris secara sukarela)—berhasil menjembatani mandat hukum formal dengan prinsip keadilan sosial-budaya.
Zitieren
APA
Mutmainnah, I., Abdulllah, S., Jusniati, Firmansyah, A., & Aulia, R. (2020). Settlement of Customary and Islamic Inheritance Disputes in Indonesia: Analysis of Choice of Law and the Authority of Religious Courts and General Courts. Selaparang: Journal of Law Studies, 1(2). https://doi.org/10.66277/sejals.1.2.76
Vancouver
Mutmainnah I, Abdulllah S, Jusniati, Firmansyah A, Aulia R. Settlement of Customary and Islamic Inheritance Disputes in Indonesia: Analysis of Choice of Law and the Authority of Religious Courts and General Courts. Selaparang: Journal of Law Studies. 2020;1(2). doi:10.66277/sejals.1.2.76
BibTeX
@article{Mutmainnah2020,
author = {Mutmainnah, Inayatul and Abdulllah, Subhan and Jusniati and Firmansyah, Agung and Aulia, Rohima},
title = {Settlement of Customary and Islamic Inheritance Disputes in Indonesia: Analysis of Choice of Law and the Authority of Religious Courts and General Courts},
journal = {Selaparang: Journal of Law Studies},
year = {2020},
volume = {1},
number = {2},
doi = {10.66277/sejals.1.2.76}
}
EUVIMED