Is the GSIS-SSS Seed Capital in the Maharlika Fund a Tax?: A Comment on House Bill No. 6398, s. 2022
Philippine Law Journal · 31.05.2023 · 237
DOI: 10.66077/plj.vhku9830 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Philippine Law Journal, online erschienen am 31.05.2023. Verfasst von Jan Fredrick Cruz.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The Maharlika Investment Fund, a priority in the legislative agenda of President Ferdinand Marcos Jr., will soon become a reality as the House of Representatives and the Senate have passed respective bills providing for this. While the very concept of a sovereign wealth fund ("SWF") has faced various pushbacks and controversies since its inception, the most vocal dissent has stemmed from the proposed use of social security funds for the initial capitalization of the SWF-as contained in House Bill No. 6398, s. 2022, the first Maharlika Fund bill. Even if the most recent Maharlika proposal deletes the infusion of social security monies in the SWF, nothing prevents Congress from exercising its lawmaking prerogative to revive the capitalization funding from the Government Service Insurance System (GSIS) and Social Security System (SSS) through an amendatory law. This article explains why such a move is legally untenable from the lens of tax law and constitutional law principles. The paper recaps rudimentary jurisprudence on taxation. Proceeding from this review, the article then argues that any mandatory contribution of GSIS and SSS funds to the SWF by way of legislation constitutes a form of confiscatory taxation on capital. Hence, a statutorily obligated capital infusion from GSIS and SSS to the Maharlika Fund is an unconstitutional levy.
Zitieren
APA
Cruz, J. F. (2023). Is the GSIS-SSS Seed Capital in the Maharlika Fund a Tax?: A Comment on House Bill No. 6398, s. 2022. Philippine Law Journal, 237. https://doi.org/10.66077/plj.vhku9830
Vancouver
Cruz JF. Is the GSIS-SSS Seed Capital in the Maharlika Fund a Tax?: A Comment on House Bill No. 6398, s. 2022. Philippine Law Journal. 2023:237. doi:10.66077/plj.vhku9830
BibTeX
@article{Cruz2023,
author = {Cruz, Jan Fredrick},
title = {Is the GSIS-SSS Seed Capital in the Maharlika Fund a Tax?: A Comment on House Bill No. 6398, s. 2022},
journal = {Philippine Law Journal},
year = {2023},
pages = {237},
doi = {10.66077/plj.vhku9830}
}
EUVIMED