Direction, Time and Ether in the Padārthatattvanirūpaṇa: A Critical Metaphysical Reappraisal
Devabhumisaurabham · 15.07.2026 · 3 (1) · 544-556
DOI: 10.65833/dbs.2026.354 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Devabhumisaurabham, online erschienen am 15.07.2026. Verfasst von Sudipta Mondal.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Raghunatha Siromani, widely recognized as one of the most brilliant thinkers of the Navya-Nyaya tradition, undertook a profound and independent re-evaluation of the padārthas — the fundamental categories of reality — in his celebrated treatise, Padārthatattvanirūpaṇa. This distinguished work holds a place of special importance among his philosophical writings and may rightly be regarded as a jewel within his intellectual corpus. It bears testimony not only to his exceptional analytical insight but also to his unwavering commitment to philosophical precision and rigor. The Padārthatattvanirūpaṇa rests firmly upon both scriptural testimony (pramāṇa) and logical reasoning (yukti). Raghunatha neither confines himself to inherited tradition nor relies solely upon abstract rational argumentation. Instead, he harmoniously combines these two sources of knowledge, thereby reinforcing the epistemological strength of his conclusions. His approach exemplifies a thoughtful equilibrium between deep respect for tradition and fearless critical inquiry. Although the treatise belongs broadly to the Nyaya-Vaisheshika philosophical lineage, it does not merely restate or defend its established doctrines. Rather, Raghunatha subjects the traditional categories to careful scrutiny, re-examining their definitions, scope, and ontological status. In certain instances, he proposes modifications and refinements that reveal his independent philosophical judgment. Significantly, he does not hesitate to incorporate certain categories acknowledged by the Mimamsa school, even when such acceptance diverges from conventional Nyaya-Vaisheshika positions. This intellectual openness underscores his freedom from sectarian rigidity and his dedication to the pursuit of philosophical truth. Among the various topics explored in the Padārthatattvanirūpaṇa, the concepts of Direction, Time and Ether occupy an important place. Raghunatha Siromani does not accept dik (direction) as an additional substance (dravya). According to him, dik is non-different from Īśvara. If Īśvara, delimited by a particular adjunct (upādhi) in the form of divided spatial distinctions, is accepted as the cause of the cognition of spatial remoteness (daiśika paratva) and proximity (aparatva), then the usage of terms such as ‘east,’ ‘west,’ ‘remoteness,’ and ‘proximity’ can be logically explained. Therefore, there is no need to admit dik as a substance distinct from Īśvara. Once the indivisible (akhaṇḍa), all-pervasive (vibhu), eternal (nitya) Parameśvara is accepted as the cause of the world, it is unreasonable to posit another all-pervasive substance in the form of dik as something over and above Him. With regard to Time, Raghunatha offers a newer interpretation. According to the ancient doctrine, just as kāla is an all-pervasive (vibhu) substance, so too is Īśvara. Therefore, instead of admitting an independent Mahākāla through the relational term involved in the previously mentioned chain of relations (paramparā-sambandha), it is more appropriate to accept Īśvara Himself the vibhu substance — as the ultimate referent. Similarly, Raghunatha Siromani argues that there is no necessity to admit, over and above the eight substances such as earth, a distinct substance called ākāśa on the ground that it is the samavāyi cause of sound (śabda). Accordingly, the present study represents a sincere and sustained effort to examine, analyze, and elucidate the various dimensions, implications, and scope of the concepts of Direction, Time, and Ether as articulated in the Padārthatattvanirūpaṇa. By bringing together dispersed arguments and clarifying their philosophical significance, this work seeks to provide a coherent and critical understanding of Raghunatha’s metaphysical reflections within the larger context of Navya-Nyaya thought.
Zitieren
APA
Mondal, S. (2026). Direction, Time and Ether in the Padārthatattvanirūpaṇa: A Critical Metaphysical Reappraisal. Devabhumisaurabham, 3(1), 544-556. https://doi.org/10.65833/dbs.2026.354
Vancouver
Mondal S. Direction, Time and Ether in the Padārthatattvanirūpaṇa: A Critical Metaphysical Reappraisal. Devabhumisaurabham. 2026;3(1):544-556. doi:10.65833/dbs.2026.354
BibTeX
@article{Mondal2026,
author = {Mondal, Sudipta},
title = {Direction, Time and Ether in the Padārthatattvanirūpaṇa: A Critical Metaphysical Reappraisal},
journal = {Devabhumisaurabham},
year = {2026},
volume = {3},
number = {1},
pages = {544--556},
doi = {10.65833/dbs.2026.354}
}
EUVIMED