EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

Misreading Plato: Rehabilitating Platonic Aesthetics through an Analysis of Mimesis

Vina CHOI

Institute of X-Cultural Studies · 30.06.2026 · 2 (1) · 9-57

DOI: 10.65560/xcs.2026.2.1.9 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Institute of X-Cultural Studies, online erschienen am 30.06.2026. Verfasst von Vina CHOI.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Since Nietzsche, Western aesthetic history has defined Plato as the "enemy of art." This view has become something of a scholarly orthodoxy, confirmed by figures as diverse as Danto, Nehamas, and Porter. The present paper questions this 2,400-year-old consensus through a close reading of Plato's original texts, focusing on the arguments of three key scholars: Nehamas, Halliwell, and Grethlein. Nehamas argues that Plato's target of criticism was not "art" itself, but rather the popular performances of his time that falsely claimed the authority of truth. Halliwell demonstrates systematically that throughout Plato's work, mimesis is not a single negative concept but possesses multiple layers of meaning: personal narrative, the replication of appearance, the simulation of nature, self-formation modeled after the Ideas, and mediation. Grethlein contends that Plato's analysis of aesthetic experience anticipates findings now confirmed by modern cognitive science — among them embodied cognition, neuroplasticity, and VR psychotherapy. Furthermore, this paper argues that the conventional reading of Plato's censorship of art does not reflect the full texture of the text. This is evident in Socrates' confession of love for Homer (595b), his open invitation for poetry to defend itself in the city (607c–d), and his acceptance of hymns to the gods and praises of good men (607a). The Diotima speech in the Symposium and the theory of beauty in the Phaedrus together show that sensory experience serves as an essential channel to the Ideas — a pathway for which Spinoza's epistemology provides an ontological foundation. Drawing these strands together, this paper identifies three distinct layers of misreading in the received interpretation of Plato: the anachronistic projection of categories (Nehamas), the unification of a fundamentally plural concept (Halliwell), and the misreading of his underlying attitude (Grethlein). Through this analysis, I argue that what Plato rejected was not art as such, but a specific artistic practice — one that replicates mere appearances without grasping their essence and falsely claims the authority of truth in doing so. Finally, this paper addresses the ontological tensions arising from Plato's separation of Ideas and sensory experience by drawing on the Neo-Confucian philosophy of Yi Toegye (李退溪), particularly his concept of li (理, Principle). This framework opens the possibility of transitioning from mimesis — the replication of appearance — to xianshi (顯⽰ manifestation). The practice of gyeong (敬, reverential attentiveness) as a mode of artistic discovery is not the object of Plato's critique; rather, it represents the artistic equivalent of self-formation modeled after the Ideas — precisely the form of mimesis Plato demanded of the philosopher. Plato's criticism of art should therefore be understood not as a wholesale condemnation, but as a critique of a particular practice that imitates appearances without grasping their essence and thereby usurps the authority of truth.

Zitieren

APA

CHOI, V. (2026). Misreading Plato: Rehabilitating Platonic Aesthetics through an Analysis of Mimesis. Institute of X-Cultural Studies, 2(1), 9-57. https://doi.org/10.65560/xcs.2026.2.1.9

Vancouver

CHOI V. Misreading Plato: Rehabilitating Platonic Aesthetics through an Analysis of Mimesis. Institute of X-Cultural Studies. 2026;2(1):9-57. doi:10.65560/xcs.2026.2.1.9

BibTeX
@article{CHOI2026,
  author = {CHOI, Vina},
  title = {Misreading Plato: Rehabilitating Platonic Aesthetics through an Analysis of Mimesis},
  journal = {Institute of X-Cultural Studies},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {2},
  number = {1},
  pages = {9--57},
  doi = {10.65560/xcs.2026.2.1.9}
}
Kostenlos starten →