EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Open Access · CC BY-NC-SA 4.0

Fetus Feuds

Summer Carne

The Stellenbosch Socratic Journal · 25.11.2022 · 2 · 23-31

DOI: 10.65407/carne2022 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift The Stellenbosch Socratic Journal, online erschienen am 25.11.2022. Verfasst von Summer Carne. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC-SA 4.0).

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitieren

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Judith Jarvis Thomson's article, A Defense of Abortion, covers a deeply debated subject in moral philosophy due to its controversial and powerful stance in favour of the right to have an abortion. In this paper, I critique her work and in so doing, aim to affirm her position that abortion is morally permissible. I analyse the hypothetical scenarios Thomson uses for her position which include The Violinist, The Engulfing Baby, The Jacket, and The Burglar. Upon close inspection, the core argument of each of these analogies proves that the right to make decisions about one's body and the right to self-defence are stronger than that of the fetus's use of one's body. As will be discussed, her paper does not go without criticism. John Finnis argues that the fetus has ownership rights which should not be violated through abortion. However, his argument is weakened, because it cannot be applied when a pregnancy is life threatening. This would violate the mother's ownership rights. I will contend that Thomson's "right to autonomy" argument, in favour of the right to abort, is more pertinent than Finnis' claim, because it can be applied to all situations. Another well-known point of discussion, proposed as the dilemma of "actively killing" or "allowing to die" by Philippa Foot, will also be examined. In this paper, I contend that Foot's concern is less relevant than Thomson's, given that aborting would be followed by an already available sequence of events that does not impact the overall moral right to autonomy. With these convincing critiques, I conclude that Foot's dilemma dissipates, and we are left with the argument that Thomson's right to autonomy in favour of the moral permissibility of abortion prevails.

Zitieren

APA

Carne, S. (2022). Fetus Feuds. The Stellenbosch Socratic Journal, 2, 23-31. https://doi.org/10.65407/carne2022

Vancouver

Carne S. Fetus Feuds. The Stellenbosch Socratic Journal. 2022;2:23-31. doi:10.65407/carne2022

BibTeX
@article{Carne2022,
  author = {Carne, Summer},
  title = {Fetus Feuds},
  journal = {The Stellenbosch Socratic Journal},
  year = {2022},
  volume = {2},
  pages = {23--31},
  doi = {10.65407/carne2022}
}
Kostenlos starten →