It is Hard to be an Transmedia God: from the Cult Status of the Novel to the Failure of the Television Series (American Gods)
Issues of Media Business · 01.04.2026 · 123
DOI: 10.65324/imb025 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Issues of Media Business, online erschienen am 01.04.2026. Verfasst von Vladimir Balash und 2 weiteren Autor:innen. Die Arbeit nennt 33 Literaturangaben.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The article offers an analysis of the unsuccessful transmedia transition from Neil Gaiman’s cult novel American Gods to its television adaptation, which suffered both strategic and artistic failure. The authors examine the series as an indicator of the limits of transmediality in the contemporary media environment, reflecting the tensions between different forms of affective mediality underlying literary and audiovisual experience. Drawing on a media-philosophical approach, the authors overcome the constraints of the semiotic model of transmediality proposed by H. Jenkins and C. Scolari, emphasizing the significance of the embodied and affective dimensions of media impact. On this methodological basis, the article argues that a successful transmedia project requires not only the coordination of narrative and symbolic structures but also the transfer of specific sensory modes of perception, which in the case of American Gods proved unattainable. Gaiman’s novel is examined as a paradigm of textual cult status, grounded in the effect of living mythology and the reader’s experience of intimate contact with divine agents. This structure aligns with biological and cognitive preconditions of religious imagination, including the modeling of agency, expectations of exchange, and emotional responses to the presence of the supernatural. The series, by contrast, appears as a visually saturated yet affectively truncated form, in which gods become aesthetic phenomena deprived of participation in social exchange with characters and viewers. This rupture undermines the mechanisms of religious plausibility and explains the emotional distancing of the audience. In the institutional context, the article associates the failure of the series with a conflict between niche and mass marketing strategies within platform-based media economies. The series ultimately addresses a narrow audience attuned to visual experimentation but fails to meet the expectations of the broader market. The authors conclude that the American Gods project illustrates the limits of digital visualisation as a means of sustaining cult potential, thereby exposing the importance of the media channel as a condition for preserving the cultural status of a work.
Zitieren
APA
Balash, V., Mikhaylin, V., & Tikhonova, S. (2026). It is Hard to be an Transmedia God: from the Cult Status of the Novel to the Failure of the Television Series (American Gods). Issues of Media Business, 123. https://doi.org/10.65324/imb025
Vancouver
Balash V, Mikhaylin V, Tikhonova S. It is Hard to be an Transmedia God: from the Cult Status of the Novel to the Failure of the Television Series (American Gods). Issues of Media Business. 2026:123. doi:10.65324/imb025
BibTeX
@article{Balash2026,
author = {Balash, Vladimir and Mikhaylin, Vadim and Tikhonova, Sophia},
title = {It is Hard to be an Transmedia God: from the Cult Status of the Novel to the Failure of the Television Series (American Gods)},
journal = {Issues of Media Business},
year = {2026},
pages = {123},
doi = {10.65324/imb025}
}
EUVIMED