Integration of Medical Science and Criminal Law: A Study of Insanity Defense in India
International Multidisciplinary Knowledge Exchange Journal · 31.03.2026 · 1 (2) · 119-128
DOI: 10.65282/imke.vol.1.issue.02.014 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift International Multidisciplinary Knowledge Exchange Journal, online erschienen am 31.03.2026. Verfasst von Pratiksha Kelkar und 1 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
: Within the Indian legal framework, the insanity defense reflects the ongoing struggle to reconcile scientific knowledge of mental disorders with established legal principles of accountability. The insanity defense, earlier in Section 84 of the Indian Penal Code and now in Section 22 of the Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita, means that a person is not criminally liable if, due to a mental disorder, he or she could not understand what he or she was doing or tell right from wrong. This principle is derived from R v McNaughten (1843), decided by the House of Lords in the United Kingdom, which introduced the cognitive test for determining legal insanity. It reflects medical understanding from the nineteenth century whereas modern psychiatry and neuroscience have provided new insights into how the brain works, including impulse control and decision-making. The distinction between legal and medical insanity often leads to ambiguities, inconsistent judicial decisions, and challenges in interpreting psychiatric evaluations within a legal framework. Though psychiatric evidence is accepted, advances in neuroscience have not yet significantly influenced how Insanity is interpreted. This creates a gap between modern scientific understanding of mental disorders and the legal standards for criminal responsibility. As a result, individuals suffering from serious but non-cognitive mental disorders may be unfairly held criminally responsible, leading to potential miscarriages of justice. This study seeks to examine the integration of medical science and criminal law in India by analysing the legal provisions, judicial practices, and medical assessments associated with the insanity defense. The research uses a doctrinal and analytical approach, examining case laws, statutes, and scholarly literature. It seeks to identify gaps between medical and legal interpretations of mental illness and assess their impact on judicial decisions. The research also assumes that better cooperation between legal professionals and psychiatrists can make the application of the insanity defense fairer and more reliable, while safeguarding public safety and individual rights.
Zitieren
APA
Kelkar, P., & Agarwal, M. (2026). Integration of Medical Science and Criminal Law: A Study of Insanity Defense in India. International Multidisciplinary Knowledge Exchange Journal, 1(2), 119-128. https://doi.org/10.65282/imke.vol.1.issue.02.014
Vancouver
Kelkar P, Agarwal M. Integration of Medical Science and Criminal Law: A Study of Insanity Defense in India. International Multidisciplinary Knowledge Exchange Journal. 2026;1(2):119-128. doi:10.65282/imke.vol.1.issue.02.014
BibTeX
@article{Kelkar2026,
author = {Kelkar, Pratiksha and Agarwal, Manisha},
title = {Integration of Medical Science and Criminal Law: A Study of Insanity Defense in India},
journal = {International Multidisciplinary Knowledge Exchange Journal},
year = {2026},
volume = {1},
number = {2},
pages = {119--128},
doi = {10.65282/imke.vol.1.issue.02.014}
}
EUVIMED