Between a Knee and a Wrist Slap: Dissecting Courtroom Humour across a Public-Practitioner Divide
The Oxford Journal of Student Scholarship · 2026-10
DOI: 10.65161/rectypgxlanutdlh1 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift The Oxford Journal of Student Scholarship, 2026-10. Verfasst von Prisha Sharma.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Courts are viewed as rational, objective, even solemn institutions, upholding law and maintaining social order.However, legal battles inherently trigger biological 'fight-or-flight' responses.While humour can act as a crucial safety valve, discharging this nervous energy, it simultaneously risks causing contempt, bias, or professional violations.Current literature often overlooks the exact boundaries of this tension; this paper addresses that gap by investigating what differentiates a benign icebreaker from a disruptive breach of courtroom decorum.This study employs an ethnomethodological approach, analysing the micro-decisions of legal actors by analysing on-screen courtroom depictions and qualitative responses of industry professionals.Coupled with audience-rating exercises, they gauge external perceptions of legal wit.Analysed through frameworks of Superiority, Relief, and Benign-Violation theories, findings reveal that successful courtroom humour is multifaceted rather than a singular, calculated tactic.It manifests across a spectrum: as an oppressive tool to assert authority, a tentative coping mechanism for nervous energy, or a natural, instinctual human impulse to find lightness in high-pressure environments.Its success and appropriateness fundamentally depends on how these diverse motivations interact within each institutional setting.Practitioner responses entail an evident structural distribution of humour, shaped by privilege and hierarchy.On a 5-point Likert scale from strongly disagree to strongly agree, 85.7% of respondents selected a 3 or higher, heavily agreeing that judges who wield humour 'humanise' the court, whereas lawyers who do the same risk the court's respect.Nonetheless, an equal 85.7% tend to disagree that they consciously edit humorous remarks to ensure appropriateness.Ultimately, this research demonstrates that humor is not an ornamental lapse of decorum or a mere distraction.Rather, it serves as a functional, calculated strategy essential for maintaining socio-psychological boundaries, authority, and fostering cooperation within the legal system.
Zitieren
APA
Sharma, P. (2026). Between a Knee and a Wrist Slap: Dissecting Courtroom Humour across a Public-Practitioner Divide. The Oxford Journal of Student Scholarship. https://doi.org/10.65161/rectypgxlanutdlh1
Vancouver
Sharma P. Between a Knee and a Wrist Slap: Dissecting Courtroom Humour across a Public-Practitioner Divide. The Oxford Journal of Student Scholarship. 2026. doi:10.65161/rectypgxlanutdlh1
BibTeX
@article{Sharma2026,
author = {Sharma, Prisha},
title = {Between a Knee and a Wrist Slap: Dissecting Courtroom Humour across a Public-Practitioner Divide},
journal = {The Oxford Journal of Student Scholarship},
year = {2026},
doi = {10.65161/rectypgxlanutdlh1}
}
EUVIMED