EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

Two Safeties, Ten States: A Clinical-Functional Ontology of Human Regulatory States Beyond the Polyvagal Debate

Stoyan Vezenkov, Violeta Manolova

Nootism · 09.06.2026 · 2 (3) · 4-37

DOI: 10.64441/nootism.2.3.1 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Nootism, online erschienen am 09.06.2026. Verfasst von Stoyan Vezenkov und 1 weiteren Autor:innen.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Objective

Current trauma-informed clinical practice and autonomic monitoring require a more differentiated regulatory-state ontology than existing stress/recovery models. While Polyvagal theory provided an influential map for three decades, its anatomical and psychophysiological premises are the subject of an unresolved dispute: they have been challenged as untenable and defended as mischaracterized by that challenge. This paper does not adjudicate the dispute. It brackets the contested claims and reconstructs the inherited clinical map at a methodologically explicit functional level, preserving its clinical utility on grounds that do not depend on the outcome. Approach. We specify a three-level framework distinguishing anatomical, psychophysiological, and clinical-functional claims. By translating polyvagal vocabulary into level-explicit terminology, we define regulatory states as functional configurations rather than direct expressions of discrete neural pathways. Proposed framework. We propose a ten-state ontology organized along seven functional axes: safety appraisal, arousal, flexibility, social availability, source of regulation, internal integration, and reality-referencing. These states are grouped into three families: open (relational) safety, defense, and closed safety. Beyond preserving the inherited map, the framework adds three original specifications: the distinction between open safety, which preserves access to a shared world, and closed safety, which quiets the organism by narrowing it; the reality-referencing axis, which separates a system anchored in a shared world from one anchored in a self-referential field; and, on that axis, the differentiation of two closed-safety attractors – cue-bound contractive closure (C1), in which consensual reality remains the avoided reference, and self-referential closure (C2), in which the operational criterion of reality has migrated inward. The ten-state map further adds low-arousal relational co-regulation (O5), separating solitary restorative rest from active, low-demand relational contact.

Conclusions

By changing the level of analysis rather than taking a side in the dispute, this reconstruction preserves the utility of the inherited clinical map while specifying new state discriminations and falsifiable predictions, each answerable to evidence at its own level. A central prediction addresses a common autonomic–relational dissociation: deep inverted-referent states may display favorable autonomic indices despite severe impairment in shared-world access. The result is a five-way discrimination among configurations that may all present as quiet – restorative regulation (O1), low-arousal relational co-regulation (O5), defensive collapse (D3), cue-bound contractive closure (C1), and self-referential closure (C2) – which the inherited three-state map could not state. Open safety is therefore not autonomic quieting as such, but regulation that preserves access to shared reality, reciprocal contact, and developmental movement. Keywords: polyvagal theory; regulatory states; open safety; closed safety; reality-referencing; self-referential closure; screen trauma; HRV interpretation

Zitieren

APA

Vezenkov, S., & Manolova, V. (2026). Two Safeties, Ten States: A Clinical-Functional Ontology of Human Regulatory States Beyond the Polyvagal Debate. Nootism, 2(3), 4-37. https://doi.org/10.64441/nootism.2.3.1

Vancouver

Vezenkov S, Manolova V. Two Safeties, Ten States: A Clinical-Functional Ontology of Human Regulatory States Beyond the Polyvagal Debate. Nootism. 2026;2(3):4-37. doi:10.64441/nootism.2.3.1

BibTeX
@article{Vezenkov2026,
  author = {Vezenkov, Stoyan and Manolova, Violeta},
  title = {Two Safeties, Ten States: A Clinical-Functional Ontology of Human Regulatory States Beyond the Polyvagal Debate},
  journal = {Nootism},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {2},
  number = {3},
  pages = {4--37},
  doi = {10.64441/nootism.2.3.1}
}
Kostenlos starten →