History, Political Action and Change as “Aberrations”, and Zionism as an Irremediable “Contradiction”
Israel Social Science Research · 01.06.1983 · 1 (2) · 69-76
DOI: 10.64166/thvfv361 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Israel Social Science Research, online erschienen am 01.06.1983. Verfasst von Henry Rosenfeld. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
There is much to recommend in Lustick’s book. This is so especiaily in the chosen area of his study, in the way he spells out systematically how the Israeli regime has maintained control over its Arab national minority (approximately 14-15% of the 3,725000 Israeli population). There is no gainsaying most of the facts, reports and assembled interviews in this well-researched document. I find serious fault, however, with the model that Lustick, a political scientist, follows in his work (variants of the model can also be found among sociologists who relate to the subject, e.g., Smooha, 1978; Zureik, 1979), with his interpretation of many of the facts, and with the theoretical cushion upon which he allows his model to rest. In brief, my main criticism is that Lustick treats the forces that contest and mitigate the political control system as “aberrations”, outside the model. Moreover, once such forces are taken into account in the study, they are vitiated by the raising of a spectre of irresolvable contradictions inherent in Zionism and in the immanent “Jewish character” of the Israeli state. Whatever else, these contradictions will keep the control system (and the model) ever operative, and the controllers and controlled ever in their place. This is no small matter since, finally, according to this guiding (non-dynamic) methodology, there is no hope whatsoever that political and ideological activity may change conditions.
Zitieren
APA
Rosenfeld, H. (1983). History, Political Action and Change as “Aberrations”, and Zionism as an Irremediable “Contradiction”. Israel Social Science Research, 1(2), 69-76. https://doi.org/10.64166/thvfv361
Vancouver
Rosenfeld H. History, Political Action and Change as “Aberrations”, and Zionism as an Irremediable “Contradiction”. Israel Social Science Research. 1983;1(2):69-76. doi:10.64166/thvfv361
BibTeX
@article{Rosenfeld1983,
author = {Rosenfeld, Henry},
title = {History, Political Action and Change as “Aberrations”, and Zionism as an Irremediable “Contradiction”},
journal = {Israel Social Science Research},
year = {1983},
volume = {1},
number = {2},
pages = {69--76},
doi = {10.64166/thvfv361}
}
EUVIMED