Product liability for neurostimulation harms: comparative legal review of the revised European Union directive, United States preemption and other regimes
NeuroData · 19.07.2025 · 2 · 121
DOI: 10.63688/neurodata2025121 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift NeuroData, online erschienen am 19.07.2025. Verfasst von Erik Ricardo Condori. Die Arbeit nennt 115 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Implanted and wearable neurostimulators are now software-bearing products whose failures fall between medical malpractice and product liability, and the law has struggled to say which regime pays. This review examines how strict-liability systems distribute responsibility for neurostimulation harm, how the revised European Union Product Liability Directive alters the position of injured patients, and how United States preemption doctrine and other regimes compare. Three conclusions emerge. First, the chokepoint in every regime is not the standard of liability but the proof of defect and causation for software-mediated injury, a burden patients rarely carry. Second, the revised directive's presumption of defectiveness and its inclusion of software within the definition of a product move that chokepoint but leave causation untouched. Third, preemption relocates the same question to a federal authorization standard that contains no comparable presumption. The review closes by identifying the barriers that remain: proof of causation across adaptive algorithms, the development-risk defence, cross-border litigation, and the absence of any compensation mechanism in the emerging neurorights instruments.
Zitieren
APA
Condori, E. R. (2025). Product liability for neurostimulation harms: comparative legal review of the revised European Union directive, United States preemption and other regimes. NeuroData, 2, 121. https://doi.org/10.63688/neurodata2025121
Vancouver
Condori ER. Product liability for neurostimulation harms: comparative legal review of the revised European Union directive, United States preemption and other regimes. NeuroData. 2025;2:121. doi:10.63688/neurodata2025121
BibTeX
@article{Condori2025,
author = {Condori, Erik Ricardo},
title = {Product liability for neurostimulation harms: comparative legal review of the revised European Union directive, United States preemption and other regimes},
journal = {NeuroData},
year = {2025},
volume = {2},
pages = {121},
doi = {10.63688/neurodata2025121}
}
EUVIMED