“I swear it was him”: Memory failure, Science and the Myth of the perfect witness in Pakistani Law. Critical analysis of Qanoon-e-Shahadat Order 1984
Journal of Political Stability Archive · 31.03.2026 · 4 (3) · 1284-1307
DOI: 10.63468/jpsa.4.3.81 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Political Stability Archive, online erschienen am 31.03.2026. Verfasst von Mahnoor Jadoon und 5 weiteren Autor:innen. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
In the criminal jurisprudence of Pakistan, the testimony of an eyewitness (Chashm-Deed Gawah) has long been regarded as one of the most persuasive forms of direct evidence. Courts frequently rely on the firsthand account of an observer to reconstruct the events of a crime and determine the guilt or innocence of the accused. The Qanoon-e-Shahadat Order 1984 (QSO), which replaced the Evidence Act of 1872, sets out the statutory framework governing the competence, examination, and credibility assessment of witnesses. Under Articles 3 and 132 of the QSO 1984, any individual capable of understanding questions and giving rational answers is competent to testify under oath and subject to cross-examination. Furthermore, trial judges are empowered under Article 150 (read alongside Article 161) to observe and evaluate the demeanor of a witness to judge their veracity. However, this traditional legal paradigm rests on a fundamental, scientifically discredited assumption: that human memory functions like a video camera, accurately recording events and retrieving them unaltered during trial. Decades of research in cognitive psychology and neurobiology demonstrate that human memory is not reproductive, but reconstructive (Loftus, 2005). Memory encoding, storage, and retrieval are inherently vulnerable to distortion, emotional trauma, physiological stress, weapon focus, and post-event contamination by external suggestions. Despite these empirical realities, Pakistani courtrooms continue to treat witness confidence and composure under cross-examination as primary indicators of factual accuracy. This divergence between legal assumptions and psychological reality creates a grave risk of wrongful convictions. In practice, investigative protocols in Pakistan exacerbate memory vulnerabilities. Test Identification Parades (TIP), regulated under Article 22 of the QSO 1984, are routinely conducted in ways that expose witnesses to subtle investigator bias, police cues, and simultaneous line-up arrangements factors known to produce false positives and artificial confidence inflation. While judicial precedents, such as the landmark Supreme Court decision in PLD 2019 SC 527, emphasize the application of common sense and practical judgment when reconciling inconsistencies in witness statements (including discrepancies between Section 161 CrPC police statements and courtroom testimony), common sense alone is unequipped to detect sincere yet mistaken memories. To uphold the constitutional right to a fair trial and due process guaranteed under Article 10-A of the Constitution of Islamic Republic of Pakistan, 1973, the country’s legal framework must undergo evidence-based modernization. This paper examines the intersection of Pakistani statutory provisions, judicial practice, and psychological science regarding eyewitness reliability. It critically analyzes the procedural flaws within current identification protocols and cross-examination frameworks, arguing that existing safeguards are insufficient to filter out memory-based errors. Finally, it presents actionable statutory and procedural reforms including the adoption of double-blind sequential line-ups, standardized investigative protocols, and the admissibility of expert psychological testimony on memory to align Pakistan's criminal justice system with global scientific standards.
Zitieren
APA
Jadoon, M., Khan, A. S., Ishaq, B., Bibi, A., Hassan, A., & Rauf, K. (2026). “I swear it was him”: Memory failure, Science and the Myth of the perfect witness in Pakistani Law. Critical analysis of Qanoon-e-Shahadat Order 1984. Journal of Political Stability Archive, 4(3), 1284-1307. https://doi.org/10.63468/jpsa.4.3.81
Vancouver
Jadoon M, Khan AS, Ishaq B, Bibi A, Hassan A, Rauf K. “I swear it was him”: Memory failure, Science and the Myth of the perfect witness in Pakistani Law. Critical analysis of Qanoon-e-Shahadat Order 1984. Journal of Political Stability Archive. 2026;4(3):1284-1307. doi:10.63468/jpsa.4.3.81
BibTeX
@article{Jadoon2026,
author = {Jadoon, Mahnoor and Khan, Attiya Shafaq and Ishaq, Bilal and Bibi, Amina and Hassan, Anjal and Rauf, Kashmala},
title = {“I swear it was him”: Memory failure, Science and the Myth of the perfect witness in Pakistani Law. Critical analysis of Qanoon-e-Shahadat Order 1984},
journal = {Journal of Political Stability Archive},
year = {2026},
volume = {4},
number = {3},
pages = {1284--1307},
doi = {10.63468/jpsa.4.3.81}
}
EUVIMED