A Comparative Study of Production Waste Drivers and Contextual Fit of Lean Tools in Manufacturing Enterprises
Annals of Management 管理学年鉴 · 30.10.2026 · 1 (2) · 97
DOI: 10.63313/management.8019 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Annals of Management 管理学年鉴, online erschienen am 30.10.2026. Verfasst von Cheng Li und 1 weiteren Autor:innen. Die Arbeit nennt 17 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-SA 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Purpose
Similar manifestations of production waste do not necessarily originate from the same operating mechanism. Waiting may reflect an imbalance in workstation cycle times, a lengthy machine changeover, or interruptions in equipment operation. Inventory can be associated with shop-floor replenishment or with delays in upstream procurement, whereas excess material movement may arise from separable process steps or physical restrictions on plant layout. This study compares these distinctions in published manufacturing cases. It addresses three corresponding questions: what problem drivers and diagnostic levels can be distinguished across the cases; how the reported conditions shape tentative choices among lean interventions; and how the forms of evidence reported in the articles limit conclusions about improvement outcomes.
Methods
Five peer-reviewed studies of identifiable manufacturing production systems constitute the primary cases. They concern connector assembly, X-series product manufacturing, aerospace-part machining, ready-made garment operations, and a steel-processing facility. One additional study involving interviews with 16 engineer-to-order organisations from several industries serves as supporting evidence on implementation barriers; it is not pooled with the five production-system cases. The selection is purposive, based on subject relevance, accessible original reports, comparability of diagnostic information, and variation in manufacturing conditions. The published paper serves as the source unit, while each traceable observation concerning a problem, a reported or candidate driver, an intervention and/or an outcome is an evidence-record unit. Twenty-eight such records were reviewed in the present coding register. Reported observations, author-confirmed causes, unconfirmed candidates, implemented measures, proposed targets, calculated scenarios and reported outcomes were differentiated. Each record retains the corresponding page, table or section where available. Cross-case interpretations were separately recorded so that an inference made in this study would not be represented as a conclusion established by the original authors. Because the earlier exploratory retrieval process did not preserve a full list of search hits and exclusions, a dated supplementary verification log is provided rather than a retrospective claim of systematic-review screening. The study does not conduct independent shop-floor experiments or estimate causal effects.
Results
The comparison identifies distinct diagnostic requirements behind superficially similar production losses. In connector assembly, the original authors measured workstation cycle times, reported a line-balance rate of 75.31% before improvement, and reorganised tasks together with batch-based replenishment and buffers. The aerospace machining case reports a 120-minute milling changeover, process-routing difficulties and reliance on shared off-line measurements. Its intervention package differs from a workstation-balancing programme. In the garment case, equipment losses are decomposed through availability, performance and quality in the overall equipment effectiveness (OEE) measure. These cases support a distinction among workstation, changeover and equipment-system measurement levels. A second contrast separates internal replenishment and work-in-process control from the component-supply and just-in-time purchasing decisions discussed in the X-series case. A third contrasts process integration in isolated operations with facility-layout planning subject to overhead-crane reach, inter-bay transfer restrictions and available space. These differences inform four tentative matching situations concerning work balance, inventory and supply, equipment-related loss, and material flow or layout. The supplementary engineer-to-order interviews provide a limiting example: high product variety can make fixed error-proofing devices difficult to maintain, but the interviews do not establish the effectiveness of a replacement technology. Outcome reports also differ in evidential status. Some describe before-and-after changes following combined interventions, the X-series report labels several future-state figures as targets, the steel-processing study calculates prospective benefits of a layout alternative, and the auxiliary study reports observations from interviews. A rise in garment-system OEE from 76% to 90% represents 14 percentage points, not an independently identified effect of value-stream mapping.
Conclusion
Manufacturing managers should first identify the level at which a loss is measured and the operating conditions that generate it. Candidate lean measures can then be screened against process adjustability, replenishment reliability, equipment capabilities and physical layout constraints. The evaluation design should be aligned with whether the intervention is merely proposed, calculated or reported as implemented. The resulting tool-fit relationships are a source-traceable comparative synthesis, not a universally optimal decision algorithm. Their broader effectiveness requires additional cases, consistent operational measures and independent field verification.
Zitieren
APA
Li, C., & Dai, Z. (2026). A Comparative Study of Production Waste Drivers and Contextual Fit of Lean Tools in Manufacturing Enterprises. Annals of Management 管理学年鉴, 1(2), 97. https://doi.org/10.63313/management.8019
Vancouver
Li C, Dai Z. A Comparative Study of Production Waste Drivers and Contextual Fit of Lean Tools in Manufacturing Enterprises. Annals of Management 管理学年鉴. 2026;1(2):97. doi:10.63313/management.8019
BibTeX
@article{Li2026,
author = {Li, Cheng and Dai, Zihang},
title = {A Comparative Study of Production Waste Drivers and Contextual Fit of Lean Tools in Manufacturing Enterprises},
journal = {Annals of Management 管理学年鉴},
year = {2026},
volume = {1},
number = {2},
pages = {97},
doi = {10.63313/management.8019}
}
EUVIMED