Rethinking ESG Credibility: Conceptual Gaps, Normative Assumptions, and the Future of Sustainable Capitalism
Algora · 2024
DOI: 10.63084/algora.v1i02.55 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Algora, 2024. Verfasst von Isaiah Oluwsegun Owolabi und 3 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) frameworks have become central to sustainable finance and corporate accountability, however, their credibility remains contested. This paper critically examines the conceptual gaps, normative assumptions, and empirical challenges that undermine ESG’s capacity to drive substantive sustainability outcomes. Drawing on recent literature, we identify four core credibility challenges: definitional fragmentation across rating providers and regulatory regimes, measurement heterogeneity that prevents meaningful comparability, pervasive greenwashing enabled by disclosure-oriented rather than impact-oriented metrics, and embedded market-centric assumptions that privilege voluntary compliance over mandatory verification. Empirical evidence demonstrates that mandatory reporting requirements significantly reduce deceptive disclosure practices, while rating divergence and symbolic compliance persist under voluntary regimes. We propose a multi-level governance framework integrating harmonized taxonomies, outcome-based metrics, mandatory third-party audits, and ecocentric principles that extend beyond anthropocentric stakeholder models. This synthesis contributes to ongoing debates about ESG’s role in sustainable capitalism by articulating pathways from symbolic to substantive implementation and identifying priority areas for regulatory reform, corporate practice, and future research.
Zitieren
APA
Owolabi, I. O., Shawarira, L. M., Amadi, O., & Obiri, J. C. (2024). Rethinking ESG Credibility: Conceptual Gaps, Normative Assumptions, and the Future of Sustainable Capitalism. Algora. https://doi.org/10.63084/algora.v1i02.55
Vancouver
Owolabi IO, Shawarira LM, Amadi O, Obiri JC. Rethinking ESG Credibility: Conceptual Gaps, Normative Assumptions, and the Future of Sustainable Capitalism. Algora. 2024. doi:10.63084/algora.v1i02.55
BibTeX
@article{Owolabi2024,
author = {Owolabi, Isaiah Oluwsegun and Shawarira, Linda Michelle and Amadi, Osinachi and Obiri, Jeffrey Chukwuma},
title = {Rethinking ESG Credibility: Conceptual Gaps, Normative Assumptions, and the Future of Sustainable Capitalism},
journal = {Algora},
year = {2024},
doi = {10.63084/algora.v1i02.55}
}
EUVIMED