Right Conflicts and Institutional Balance in Access to Litigation Archives
Journal of Economics and Law · 2026-02 · 3 (1) · 87-97
DOI: 10.62517/jel.202614110 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Economics and Law, 2026-02. Verfasst von Jiayue Qin. Die Arbeit nennt 21 Literaturangaben.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The system for accessing litigation archives is undergoing a critical transition from a "management-oriented" to a "rights-oriented" paradigm. This transition has triggered profound rights conflicts: on one hand, the public interest embodied in judicial openness—such as the right to know and the right to supervise; on the other hand, the individual rights of litigation participants—such as personal dignity and the right to informational self-determination. These rights collide intensely within the medium of litigation archives, forming a complex pattern of rights conflicts. This paper delves into the jurisprudential dimension, first clarifying the nature and normative foundations of the right to know and the right to privacy, revealing that they are not simply oppositional but involve a dynamic balance of legal interests. Applying Larenz's theory of interest balancing and Alexy's principle of proportionality, this paper constructs a "three-level analytical framework" for rights conflicts: definition of the scope of rights, assessment of the degree of interference, and review of justifications. Based on this framework, the paper conducts a jurisprudential examination of China's current system, revealing deep-seated issues such as "normative ambiguity", "procedural deficiencies," and "illusory remedies." Drawing on Germany's theory of "informational self-determination", the U.S. standard of "reasonable expectation of privacy", and Japan's legislative technique of "differentiated disclosure", this paper proposes a balancing mechanism centered on the principle of proportionality: establishing the legitimacy of "openness as the rule" at the purpose level; achieving "layered and classified" refined disclosure at the means level; and constructing a closed-loop system for "rights remedies" at the procedural level. Ultimately, the system for accessing litigation archives should evolve from "institutional balance" to "jurisprudential integration," safeguarding the public's right to know while profoundly respecting personal dignity.
Zitieren
APA
Qin, J. (2026). Right Conflicts and Institutional Balance in Access to Litigation Archives. Journal of Economics and Law, 3(1), 87-97. https://doi.org/10.62517/jel.202614110
Vancouver
Qin J. Right Conflicts and Institutional Balance in Access to Litigation Archives. Journal of Economics and Law. 2026;3(1):87-97. doi:10.62517/jel.202614110
BibTeX
@article{Qin2026,
author = {Qin, Jiayue},
title = {Right Conflicts and Institutional Balance in Access to Litigation Archives},
journal = {Journal of Economics and Law},
year = {2026},
volume = {3},
number = {1},
pages = {87--97},
doi = {10.62517/jel.202614110}
}
EUVIMED