Analysis Of The Causes Of Product Defects In The Machining Process In Automotive Companies Using The Fishbone Diagram Method
Journal of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science (JEECS) | E-ISSN : 3089-5952 · 11.06.2026 · 2 (1)
DOI: 10.62379/jeecs.v2i1.43 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science (JEECS) | E-ISSN : 3089-5952, online erschienen am 11.06.2026. Verfasst von Rafli Hamid und 5 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Product defects in the machining process remain a major challenge in the automotive manufacturing industry because they directly affect product quality, production efficiency, and customer satisfaction. In cylinder head production, defects can lead to increased rework costs, production delays, and potential failures during assembly. Therefore, systematic quality control methods are required to identify dominant defects and determine their root causes. Purpose: This study aims to identify the most dominant product defects occurring in the cylinder head machining process, analyze the root causes of these defects, and propose effective corrective actions using the Pareto Diagram and Fishbone Diagram within the PDCA (Plan–Do–Check–Act) framework. Methods/Study Design/Approach: This research employed a descriptive approach using the PDCA cycle. Data were collected through direct observations, interviews with production operators and quality control inspectors, historical defect records, standard operating procedures (SOPs), and machine maintenance reports. The study analyzed production data from January to February 2026, covering 16,800 cylinder head units. Pareto Diagram analysis was used to determine defect priorities, while Fishbone Diagram analysis was applied to identify root causes related to manpower, machinery, methods, materials, and environmental factors. Results/Findings: The results indicate that “dakon” defects were the most dominant defect type, accounting for 5,140 units or more than 70% of total defects. Other defects included scratches (860 units) and rough surfaces (785 units). Root cause analysis revealed that operator non-compliance with SOPs, worn-out tools, contaminated coolant, and inadequate work methods were the primary contributing factors. Improvement actions included SOP refinement, increased operator supervision, scheduled tool replacement, coolant maintenance, and enhanced process control. Following implementation, the overall defect rate decreased significantly from approximately 38% to around ±3%, demonstrating the effectiveness of the proposed improvement strategy. The findings confirm that the integration of Pareto Diagram and Fishbone Diagram within the PDCA framework is effective for identifying dominant defects, determining root causes, and reducing defect rates in machining operations. This approach can serve as a practical reference for continuous quality improvement initiatives in the automotive manufacturing industry.
Zitieren
APA
Hamid, R., Mahfuzh, F. R., Nugroho, P., Novian, F. F., Ashom, M. S., & Prastyo, Y. (2026). Analysis Of The Causes Of Product Defects In The Machining Process In Automotive Companies Using The Fishbone Diagram Method. Journal of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science (JEECS) | E-ISSN : 3089-5952, 2(1). https://doi.org/10.62379/jeecs.v2i1.43
Vancouver
Hamid R, Mahfuzh FR, Nugroho P, Novian FF, Ashom MS, Prastyo Y. Analysis Of The Causes Of Product Defects In The Machining Process In Automotive Companies Using The Fishbone Diagram Method. Journal of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science (JEECS) | E-ISSN : 3089-5952. 2026;2(1). doi:10.62379/jeecs.v2i1.43
BibTeX
@article{Hamid2026,
author = {Hamid, Rafli and Mahfuzh, Fathur Rizqi and Nugroho, Prasetyo and Novian, Fauzan Fitrah and Ashom, Muhammad Syahrul and Prastyo, Yudi},
title = {Analysis Of The Causes Of Product Defects In The Machining Process In Automotive Companies Using The Fishbone Diagram Method},
journal = {Journal of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science (JEECS) | E-ISSN : 3089-5952},
year = {2026},
volume = {2},
number = {1},
doi = {10.62379/jeecs.v2i1.43}
}
EUVIMED