Azərbaycan Respublikasında hakimlərin məsuliyyətinin hüquqi mexanizmləri
Azerbaijani Lawyer Journal · 22.04.2026 · 27 (1) · 138-154
DOI: 10.61638/ytdw6945 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Azerbaijani Lawyer Journal, online erschienen am 22.04.2026. Verfasst von Konul Akhundova.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
International legal regulation of judicial accountability is grounded in the normative instruments of the United Nations and the Council of Europe, as well as in the fundamental principles of judicial independence, impartiality, and institutional and legal guarantees enshrined in the European Charter. These instruments proceed from the premise that holding judges accountable for the exercise of their powers is permissible solely within procedural frameworks that comply with the requirements of the rule of law and fair trial standards, with mandatory safeguards of procedural transparency, the right to defence, and the principle of proportionality. According to international standards, disciplinary, civil, and criminal liability of judges must not be transformed into a means of interference with their independent exercise of judicial functions. On the contrary, such mechanisms are intended to preserve public confidence in the judiciary and to enhance the quality of justice. In this context, judicial accountability is not punitive in nature but is predominantly oriented toward prevention, the reinforcement of ethical foundations, and the observance of professional conduct standards. The legislation of the Republic of Azerbaijan, following these international approaches, has shaped the institution of judicial accountability on the basis of ensuring a balance between the principle of judicial immunity and the requirement of equality of all before the law. Criminal liability of a judge is applied exclusively within a special procedural framework and is limited to cases in which the judge’s guilt has been established by a final and binding judicial conviction rendered as a result of due judicial proceedings. Such an approach, on the one hand, guarantees protection of judges against unfounded prosecution and, on the other, ensures the inevitability of their personal liability for unlawful acts. Within the framework of civil liability, in accordance with international practice, compensation for damage caused by a judge in the course of exercising official powers is provided not by the judge personally but by the state. This model ensures effective legal protection of injured parties while simultaneously preventing undue pressure on judges when making decisions as a result of potential personal financial risks. At the same time, subsequent recovery of the compensation paid from the judge by way of recourse, where the judge’s fault is proven, serves as a mechanism that maintains a balance between accountability and justice. The conducted scholarly analysis indicates that the institution of holding judges administratively liable should be applied with particular caution, since an expansive interpretation of this mechanism may lead to an increase in the influence of executive authorities over the judiciary. Such risks may have an adverse impact on the institutional independence of the judiciary and the impartiality of judges in the administration of justice. Disciplinary liability, in turn, constitutes one of the key legal mechanisms aimed at ensuring judges’ compliance with professional conduct rules, strengthening ethical standards, and preserving public confidence in the judicial system. At the same time, disciplinary proceedings must be conducted in strict conformity with international standards by independent bodies, on the basis of clearly regulated procedures, and with scrupulous observance of the principles of a fair hearing. Keywords: judge, responsibility, criminal liability, administrative liability, disciplinary liability, civil liability, immunity, sanctions, disciplinary measures, compensation for damages.
Zitieren
APA
Akhundova, K. (2026). Azərbaycan Respublikasında hakimlərin məsuliyyətinin hüquqi mexanizmləri. Azerbaijani Lawyer Journal, 27(1), 138-154. https://doi.org/10.61638/ytdw6945
Vancouver
Akhundova K. Azərbaycan Respublikasında hakimlərin məsuliyyətinin hüquqi mexanizmləri. Azerbaijani Lawyer Journal. 2026;27(1):138-154. doi:10.61638/ytdw6945
BibTeX
@article{Akhundova2026,
author = {Akhundova, Konul},
title = {Azərbaycan Respublikasında hakimlərin məsuliyyətinin hüquqi mexanizmləri},
journal = {Azerbaijani Lawyer Journal},
year = {2026},
volume = {27},
number = {1},
pages = {138--154},
doi = {10.61638/ytdw6945}
}
EUVIMED