The practice and exploration of argument-based pedagogy through academic controversy in an eight-year medical immunology program: A case study of the “Nobel Prize Controversy Involving Liping Chen”
Progress in Medical Education · 01.04.2026 · 2 (1) · 10-15
DOI: 10.61189/466869iuwenb ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Progress in Medical Education, online erschienen am 01.04.2026. Verfasst von Liyuan Zhao und 3 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Eight-year medical programs aim to train physician-scientists capable of critically evaluating evidence and navigating complex ethical dilemmas. Medical Immunology, straddling multiple disciplines, can nurture these abilities. We hypothesized that a structured academic controversy (SAC), centered on a high-profile scientific dispute, could simultaneously reinforce conceptual understanding and foster higher-order thinking. A two-hour, debate-based seminar was conducted one week after lectures on B-lymphocyte and antibody-mediated immunity. The case focused on the "Lieping Chen Nobel Prize controversy" concerning priority in the discovery of the PD-1/PD-L1 pathway. A pre-class micro-package—including original article from Proceedings of the National Academ of Sciences of the United States of America, excerpts from the Nobel white-paper, and a three-minute animation—was provided to prime students. In class, students were ran domly assigned to pro-or con-teams and engaged in a 50-minute timed debate, followed by rebuttals after switching positions. Real-time rubrics, a 6-item Likert scale (assessing critical thinking and ethical sensitivity), and 60-second post-class voice reflections provided multi-source evaluation data. The mean critical-thinking score rose from 3.2 to 4.1 (p
Zitieren
APA
Zhao, L., Tao, Y., Zhang, M., & Xu, S. (2026). The practice and exploration of argument-based pedagogy through academic controversy in an eight-year medical immunology program: A case study of the “Nobel Prize Controversy Involving Liping Chen”. Progress in Medical Education, 2(1), 10-15. https://doi.org/10.61189/466869iuwenb
Vancouver
Zhao L, Tao Y, Zhang M, Xu S. The practice and exploration of argument-based pedagogy through academic controversy in an eight-year medical immunology program: A case study of the “Nobel Prize Controversy Involving Liping Chen”. Progress in Medical Education. 2026;2(1):10-15. doi:10.61189/466869iuwenb
BibTeX
@article{Zhao2026,
author = {Zhao, Liyuan and Tao, Yijie and Zhang, Min and Xu, Sheng},
title = {The practice and exploration of argument-based pedagogy through academic controversy in an eight-year medical immunology program: A case study of the “Nobel Prize Controversy Involving Liping Chen”},
journal = {Progress in Medical Education},
year = {2026},
volume = {2},
number = {1},
pages = {10--15},
doi = {10.61189/466869iuwenb}
}
EUVIMED