Algunas limitaciones jurídicas para la implementación efectiva del marco legal en materia de ordenamiento territorial-ambiental en Uruguay
Revista de Derecho Administrativo y Urbanístico · 06.05.2026 · (6) · 47-70
DOI: 10.59709/redau.2026.6.4 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Revista de Derecho Administrativo y Urbanístico, online erschienen am 06.05.2026. Verfasst von José Sciandro.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
In Uruguay there is a broad framework of legal regulation of environmental land-use planning. Based on the analysis of recent Jurisprudence, there are limitations to enforce compliance when it is the State itself which fails to comply with the obligations established by such regulations. This is due to multiple causes, which we cannot address in this article, but from a legal perspective there are three determining elements: the limitations to challenge administrative acts due to diffuse interest or collective rights; the discretion to give content to indeterminate or open concepts widely used by the regulations referring to territorial or environmental planning and the absence of binding effect of citizen participation in decision making on common goods. The determination of when an exploitation ceases to be sustainable, when a landscape or ecosystem is relevant, or when an impact is considered negative, with few exceptions, is not objectively specified. There are usually no standards that allow an objective determination of these concepts. The instances of social participation provided for do not have any binding effect. This implies that the ultimate definition of when an impact is «significant» or an environmental damage «is serious» is left to the discretion of the head of the competent agency. The administrative acts contrary to the same regulations are protected by the constitutional limitation of requiring as a condition a personal, direct and legitimate interest to be able to challenge such acts. This represents an institutional legal framework that places the country at the forefront of the agenda for the protection of common goods, which is not matched by legal instruments that allow the control of its effective application by social organizations.
Zitieren
APA
Sciandro, J. (2026). Algunas limitaciones jurídicas para la implementación efectiva del marco legal en materia de ordenamiento territorial-ambiental en Uruguay. Revista de Derecho Administrativo y Urbanístico, 47-70. https://doi.org/10.59709/redau.2026.6.4
Vancouver
Sciandro J. Algunas limitaciones jurídicas para la implementación efectiva del marco legal en materia de ordenamiento territorial-ambiental en Uruguay. Revista de Derecho Administrativo y Urbanístico. 2026:47-70. doi:10.59709/redau.2026.6.4
BibTeX
@article{Sciandro2026,
author = {Sciandro, José},
title = {Algunas limitaciones jurídicas para la implementación efectiva del marco legal en materia de ordenamiento territorial-ambiental en Uruguay},
journal = {Revista de Derecho Administrativo y Urbanístico},
year = {2026},
number = {6},
pages = {47--70},
doi = {10.59709/redau.2026.6.4}
}
EUVIMED