Merge does not trigger a n + 1 recursive function: A reply to Mendivil-Giró (2025)
Biolinguistics · 20.04.2026 · 20
DOI: 10.5964/bioling.21979 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Biolinguistics, online erschienen am 20.04.2026. Verfasst von Diego Guerrero. Die Arbeit nennt 65 Literaturangaben. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This article examines the claim that the recursive operation Merge underlies the generative structure of the natural number system. I argue that this claim rests on a conflation between recursion as a property of syntactic representation and recursion as a property of numerical computation. In syntax, repeated applications of Merge yield hierarchically structured expressions; in arithmetic, the successor function yields successive values. These are not the same kind of operation. Focusing on recent proposals by Mendívil-Giró (2025) and Watanabe (2017), I show that Merge, whether external or internal, does not by itself derive numerical succession, but only structured symbolic objects whose interpretation must be independently determined. I further argue that the principal assumptions needed to sustain a Merge-based theory of natural number (innate numerical generativity, hierarchical structure in the count list, and a primitive lexical item corresponding to 1) lack independent empirical support. I conclude that number generativity is better understood as an emergent property of compositional symbolic structure than as the direct output of a successor-like operation implemented by narrow syntax.
Zitieren
APA
Guerrero, D. (2026). Merge does not trigger a n + 1 recursive function: A reply to Mendivil-Giró (2025). Biolinguistics, 20. https://doi.org/10.5964/bioling.21979
Vancouver
Guerrero D. Merge does not trigger a n + 1 recursive function: A reply to Mendivil-Giró (2025). Biolinguistics. 2026;20. doi:10.5964/bioling.21979
BibTeX
@article{Guerrero2026,
author = {Guerrero, Diego},
title = {Merge does not trigger a n + 1 recursive function: A reply to Mendivil-Giró (2025)},
journal = {Biolinguistics},
year = {2026},
volume = {20},
doi = {10.5964/bioling.21979}
}
EUVIMED