Explanation and Understanding Revisited
Revue roumaine de philosophie · 01.12.2025 · 69 (2) · 401-417
DOI: 10.59277/rrp.2025.69.2.14 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Revue roumaine de philosophie, online erschienen am 01.12.2025. Verfasst von Andrei Ionuț Mărășoiu.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Intuitively, it is often claimed, when we understand something, we can explain why it occurs the way it does, at least in outline. This piece of common sense is often encountered in contemporary epistemologies of understanding. Against this view, Peter Lipton distinguishes explanations from their cognitive benefits. He argues that those benefits, which lead to understanding the phenomena explained, can be obtained without recourse to explanations as well. It would follow that we can understand without being able to explain the phenomena understood. My appraisal of this debate is twofold. First, I reply, point by point, to Lipton’s objection, defending (for the purposes of argument) the view that we can only understand what we can explain. Secondly, however, I believe that this does not fully support the view that the ability to explain what one understands is a prerequisite for understanding it. Rather, I argue that differentiating between explanations (as verbal end-products of explaining), the process of explaining itself, and the cognitive benefits one may reap from understanding and/or explanation amounts to a moot distinction, which can be recast in a pluralist vein. This, I argue, questions whether the debate about how understanding and explanation relate is ultimately substantive or, at least in large part, a semantic issue concerning how we choose to devise or use key epistemological terms. I illustrate my discussion of Lipton throughout with reference to a specific model, Volterra’s equations governing the co-dependence of prey and predator species in a habitat.
Zitieren
APA
Mărășoiu, A. I. (2025). Explanation and Understanding Revisited. Revue roumaine de philosophie, 69(2), 401-417. https://doi.org/10.59277/rrp.2025.69.2.14
Vancouver
Mărășoiu AI. Explanation and Understanding Revisited. Revue roumaine de philosophie. 2025;69(2):401-417. doi:10.59277/rrp.2025.69.2.14
BibTeX
@article{Mroiu2025,
author = {Mărășoiu, Andrei Ionuț},
title = {Explanation and Understanding Revisited},
journal = {Revue roumaine de philosophie},
year = {2025},
volume = {69},
number = {2},
pages = {401--417},
doi = {10.59277/rrp.2025.69.2.14}
}
EUVIMED