Heightened Scrutiny
Educational Media Reviews Online · 30.06.2026 · 28 (6)
DOI: 10.59236/emro.v28i6a8449 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Educational Media Reviews Online, online erschienen am 30.06.2026. Verfasst von Michael Pasqualoni. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Feder, S. (Director). Scholder, A. & Mendoza, P. (Producers). (2025). Heightened Scrutiny. Disclosure Film 2 LLC. 90 mins. Heightened Scrutiny from director Sam Feder brings the viewer up close to Chase Strangio, the first trans attorney to present an oral argument before the U.S. Supreme Court. This is a recommended documentary film that depicts Strangio’s early December 2024 argument of discrimination based on sex and trans status, traversing preparations for what in the end is an adverse ruling by that highest court. Strangio works in opposition to a lower court ruling where the state of Tennessee has banned gender affirming healthcare for young people. A variety of trans persons poignantly reveal struggles navigated in a quest for their rights. The film is at its strongest when helping a viewer get to know Strangio and also twelve year old Mila and her mom, as Mila takes to a podium adjacent to U.S. Supreme Court steps on the day Strangio argues in front of those justices. While intersecting at multiple junctures with legal procedures, one is not provided with a dry law and order procedural within the film. Instead, Heightened Scrutiny occupies a more personalized introduction to these legal battles and the individuals most directly impacted by them. It is not aiming toward being a visualization of probing legal scholarship nor commentary with limited appeal to those who have attended law school. A primary thread is a reverse timeline ticking down toward Strangio’s oral argument, with audio clips of voices from that proceeding sprinkled throughout the film. There is a brush back at times to fear based arguments from right wing forces that rest atop a thin empirical basis. Valuable references are shared evoking familiar rhetorical tactics used in prior resistances of reactionary conservative political communities to movements for the rights of women in America and the advancements of African Americans, and these are well handled. So too are examinations of safety arguments employed to oppress the democratic inclusion of communities living within a distinct minority status. Particularly strong here are deconstructions of a troubling congruence between some of the specific conservative legal arguments presented to the court and associated citations to opinion journalism. Themes linked to prevalence of opinion journalism as clickbait stand out as key elements, even worrisome, it would appear, at admired outlets ranging from the Atlantic magazine to the New York Times. Looking square into the face of major legal setbacks, Heightened Scrutiny does a superb job of humanizing some of the more mechanical aspects of legal procedure in these fights for enhanced civil and human rights. Some editing choices which extend the timeline of Strangio’s preparation to legal argument up to and through the appearance at the Supreme Court on December 4, 2024, have a mixed effectiveness in what seems a noble goal of building rising action. These are competently rendered, and cinematically valid, but in part could have been lessened, in favor of spending a bit more screen time hearing at slightly greater length from any number of the trans persons and other activists and allies who support the main activities we see enacted by attorney Strangio. The filmmakers here do not attempt to spend very much time with anti-trans lawmakers or media pundits, and this might be appropriate as an avoidance of a certain “two side-ism,” which Heightened Scrutiny does a solid job criticizing alongside its other inherent media industry critiques. But even if arguments conservative forces rely upon ignore key empirical realities (e.g., percentages of persons who come to regret gender transition – as mainly a rhetorical invention), the fact of even empty arguments prevailing across so many U.S. states banning gender affirming care, perhaps that element exploring the opposition needed a tiny bit of additional coverage. If not in the voices of anti-trans politicians themselves, then a bit greater time allocated to what those whom one meets in the film have to say about the hollowness and also dangers residing within those regressive arguments. For instance, some viewers might prefer to linger a bit longer with reflections Strangio shares as to a choice of a career as a lawyer, and centrality of legal advocacy work with law being called by Strangio, a system of violence. A provocative statement that is underexamined. Even as years pass since this specific Supreme Court decision was rendered, Heightened Scrutiny will continue to be a valuable marker along the pathways toward securing greater legal rights for trans individuals, including a chronicle of setbacks during that struggle. While not first and foremost an academic framing of the issues, it nonetheless is a film offering a vivid and needed portrayal of trans persons and their allies, within a mediascape at times otherwise known for significant silence. As Strangio in preparing to face Supreme Court justices, tattoos onto his body excerpts from the poem “Prophecy,” written by the late civil rights activist and author Pauli Murray, we see an important profile in this film of an attorney breaking new ground in bringing the ongoing fight for expanded trans rights to the highest court in the United States. AwardsWinner: DocNYC Short List 2025Winner: Best Documentary 2025 Connecticut LGBTQ Film FestivalWinner: Audience Award, Runner-Up 2025 Salem Film FestivalWinner: Special Jury Award 2025 Freiburg Gay Film FestivalWinner: Best Documentary 2025 Honolulu Rainbow Film FestivalJury Mention: Documentary Feature 2025 Bentonville Film Festival
Zitieren
APA
Pasqualoni, M. (2026). Heightened Scrutiny. Educational Media Reviews Online, 28(6). https://doi.org/10.59236/emro.v28i6a8449
Vancouver
Pasqualoni M. Heightened Scrutiny. Educational Media Reviews Online. 2026;28(6). doi:10.59236/emro.v28i6a8449
BibTeX
@article{Pasqualoni2026,
author = {Pasqualoni, Michael},
title = {Heightened Scrutiny},
journal = {Educational Media Reviews Online},
year = {2026},
volume = {28},
number = {6},
doi = {10.59236/emro.v28i6a8449}
}
EUVIMED