EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Open Access · CC BY 4.0

Breaking the News

Catherine Michael

Educational Media Reviews Online · 30.06.2026 · 28 (6)

DOI: 10.59236/emro.v28i6a8448 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Educational Media Reviews Online, online erschienen am 30.06.2026. Verfasst von Catherine Michael. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitieren

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Courtney, H., et al. (Producers). Courtney, H., et al. (Directors). (2023). Breaking the News. Media Education Foundation. 95 mins. The online news publication The 19th* was co-founded by two reporters from the Texas Tribune: Emily Ramshaw (CEO) and Amanda Zamora (co-founder and publisher). Ramshaw explained the inspiration to create a publication was many: Donald Trump’s inauguration in January 2017, the Women’s March on Washington that followed, as well the #MeToo movement. She explained, “I thought women deserved a destination news platform that is just for them. It is a huge hole in the media environment that we needed to fill.” The tribulations and celebrations of the establishment of this news platform are documented in Breaking the News (2023). The title of the publication refers to the 19th Amendment, ratified in 1920, which prohibited denying the vote on the basis of sex. An asterisk signals that this right was not equally realized: Native Americans gained citizenship in 1924 but often remained disenfranchised, while Asian and Latina women faced barriers tied to citizenship and discrimination. Until 1965, poll taxes, literacy tests, and violence continued to restrict voting rights. The launch of the publication in August 2020 takes place during the pandemic. Because of the pandemic, and because staff were spread across the country (Los Angeles, Orlando, Austin, Philadelphia, etc.), a lot of shots are in the homes of the reporters. This gives the documentary an intimate feeling. Their high stress lives are supported by family and their pets; it is relatable. The film also includes clips from a variety of Zoom meetings for both fundraising and editorial purposes. Early in the film, we overhear a conversation between Zamora and Ramshaw where Zamora states at a stressful crossroads for financing the outlet, that, “I want us to be a real news organization and we’re not.” While Ramshaw is stoic and confronts issues straight on, you can see in her face and body language how difficult an endeavor establishing a news outlet is. We also see Ramshaw parenting her child. Through both private and professional moments, the film captures the strain of launching a newsroom while navigating family life and financial uncertainty. By the end of the film, post-pandemic and after a two-and-a-half-year span, everybody meets in person. We learn how the news outlet blossomed over time – including Ramshaw and Zamora now co-leading. In addition to the relationship between Ramshaw and Zamora, the documentary profiles a few award-winning reporters including Editor-at-Large, Errin Haines, who grew up in Atlanta and now reports from Philadelphia. We see her in a pitch meeting explaining why a story about Breonna Taylor is important. The story gained national attention, including coverage in The Washington Post and on MSNBC. While she is glad to have been the one to have broken the story, she is also emotionally moved by it. It was important for her that her colleagues supported her, listened to her, and were there for her. She is seen on top of other breaking stories such as Amy Cooper (a white woman who endangered a black man in a park) and Kamala Harris’s announcement to become Biden’s Vice-Presidential candidate – an exclusive interview. Chabeli Carrazana reports on the economy from Orlando. She started her career with the The Miami Herald and the The Orlando Sentinel. She was drawn to the job for its focus on people on the margins: people of color, women and LGBTQ stories. There is a scene in a live NPR interview where she is describing the pandemic economy as America’s first “female recession” while her Corgi barks; she has grace under pressure. We also see her out in the field probing the need for diapers as an economic indicator. In that context, she explains the importance of reporting conditions of poverty (she had also covered the plight of poor Disney employees in Orlando). Towards the end of the documentary, she reads out loud an emotional personal reflection about loss during the pandemic that resonated with readers. Kate Sosin reports on LGBTQ+ stories from Los Angeles. They were a national reporter for NBC News but wanted to write stories that weren’t being covered elsewhere. Sosin suggested that The 19th* needed to market themselves as gender inclusive. After being misgendered in meetings, they wondered if they made a mistake. Since leadership expressed that the work environment was “in process,” Kate decided to continue reporting. There is a scene where Abby Johnston tells Kate to “take a day” if she needs to after so much reporting on topics that are dehumanizing; they are amazed as that is not done in most newsrooms. One story highlighted concerned forms used by policymakers to draft anti-LGBTQ model legislation; it was picked up by the PBS News Hour. Later in the film, Sosin reports another impactful story on trans rural healthcare. Their honest feedback changed the paper. One suggestion was for the 19th* to hire more queer people to increase coverage of the LGBTQ+ beat; the outlet does ultimately hire another reporter. Numerous historic events are covered during the span of the documentary: the pandemic, the murders of George Floyd and Breonna Taylor, the 2020 debates, the 2020 election, the January 6, 2021 Insurrection, the Texas abortion ban of 2021, and the striking down or Roe v. Wade in June 2022. After the removal of women’s rights in Texas and with the overturning of Roe, Ramshaw understands The 19th* was prepared to cover those stories and was necessary; seeing her with her daughter on screen at that moment is poignant. Throughout the documentary, we witness Ramshaw and Zamora learn from their mistakes and address problems. They and their team openly reflect on the values and mission confronting the publication (being gender inclusive, understanding racism, inequality, what it means to be progressive) and their different work styles (Amanda calls Emily a precrastinator) and earnestly strive to resolve them. Some moments seem tense such as when they discuss the need for more beat reporters in a timely and equitable manner. As difficult as it is to be transparent with articulating the problems, doing so allows the leaders to address them and improve the publication over time. In an interview with Ramshaw by reporter Margaret Sullivan, we hear her reflect on the process of listening. At the end of the documentary, there is a revised mission statement drafted and shared. The film was produced and directed by three women: Heather Courtney, Princess A. Hairston, and Chelsea Hernandez. The editing by Jamie Boyle and Kristina Motwani was well done. Additionally, the music by Meredith Ezinma Charles and Gil Talmi match the moments on screen. The montage headlines and historical images used to tell the story flow well. One example is the use of opaque headlines and Twitter responses enhanced with a quick tweet sound. This technique illustrates the relationship between the news and the news readers. Another example is the peppy music and clips that depict the publication's launch; it captured the excitement of those involved. As a librarian working with student journalists, I assist them in discovering news articles to analyze how the press covered events and issues. The analysis makes them aware of what was covered, what was covered, how it was covered, and what was not covered. In addition to developing analytical skills, students learn about the business of the news: how do you innovate a news outlet? What is the scope and mission of the publication? Will it be for profit or not-for-profit? The documentary Breaking the News (2003) addresses both skills taught on campus: analyzing the news and understanding media economics. The documentary is highly recommended for all students, but especially students studying communications, gender studies, business, and politics. The only thing I might criticize is the title. I imagined alternatives that might describe the documentary more precisely, such as Equality & the News: The Founding of the 19th* or Writing A More Equitable Headline or Breaking the Underreported News. The documentary’s portrayal of delivering news that is fair, accurate, and equitable is commendable. Reporters deserve criticism, but they are an essential pillar of democracy and should be respected for what they do. They often work tirelessly to tell the truth. The 19th* is a success story of a newspaper launch in a difficult time for journalism. By networking with mainstream outlets, they built momentum and gained exposure. They achieved their mission of covering underreported or unreported stories. As a viewer, I came to admire them for shaping the news in an important way and against the odds. By showing the work of reporters and editors, the documentary could assist in restoring trust and respect for the press. Awards won include: Tribeca Film Festival Official Selection 2023, DC DOX Film Festival Official Selection 2023, Middlebury New Filmmakers Festival Official Selection 2023, Montclair Film Festival Official Selection 2023

Zitieren

APA

Michael, C. (2026). Breaking the News. Educational Media Reviews Online, 28(6). https://doi.org/10.59236/emro.v28i6a8448

Vancouver

Michael C. Breaking the News. Educational Media Reviews Online. 2026;28(6). doi:10.59236/emro.v28i6a8448

BibTeX
@article{Michael2026,
  author = {Michael, Catherine},
  title = {Breaking the News},
  journal = {Educational Media Reviews Online},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {28},
  number = {6},
  doi = {10.59236/emro.v28i6a8448}
}
Kostenlos starten →