Make a Circle
Educational Media Reviews Online · 20.08.2025 · 27 (8)
DOI: 10.59236/emro.v27i8a233 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Educational Media Reviews Online, online erschienen am 20.08.2025. Verfasst von Summer R. Upton. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Distributed by Good DocsProduced by Jen Bradwell, Todd Boekelheide, and Rebekah FergussonDirected by Jen Bradwell and Todd Boekelheide2024, Streaming, 89 mins Jen Bradwell & Todd Boekelheide’s Make a Circle follows the employees of three California preschools as they navigate pandemic closures in 2020 and the fight for unionization and better working conditions. The story is told through footage from these working preschools coupled with interviews with teachers both at home and at work as well as participating in community organizing events like marches. The documentary begins with footage of a baby playing, which grounds the focus of the documentary: This is the story of caring for the youngest and most vulnerable people in our society. Focus throughout the documentary never strays from footage of children playing in groups as well as interacting with teachers. The story’s pacing is not rushed. It lets the human moments breathe, which is apt in this story so rooted in humanity. Using a chronological structure and seamlessly moving between three featured preschools highlights common struggles, including low wages and lack of basic benefits. Another common theme that arises is the general misunderstanding of what happens in early childhood education, calling it “essentially babysitting” and “not real school.” One significant challenge faced by all early childcare centers in the United States was lockdown during the Covid-19 pandemic. On-screen facts and statistics support the experiences of the workers and help underscore the severity of the issue in the childcare industry. Additional on-screen facts ground the individual stories in the history of childcare in the United States back to World War II, so the audience understands that this problem has solutions that have worked in this country in the past and other countries today. One drawback of the film is that it does not cite the sources of these facts for the audience. While the documentary does not shy away from hardships of the preschool industry, the overall tone of the film is hopeful that change is possible and on the horizon. A significant portion of the film is dedicated to the fight for childcare workers to form a union—the culmination of a 20-year struggle. The union includes workers from institutions that take state subsidies. Only 2 featured preschools take state subsidies, so not all featured preschool teachers are eligible for these contract protections from the state. Even though the union struggle and contract negotiations are a focus of the story, it is the individual teacher stories that stand out. One teacher struggles with his decision to leave early childhood education for work as a 3rd and 4th grade teacher for better pay and benefits, feeling as if he is “letting [his fellow teachers] down” and abandoning his preschool students. Another teacher returns to work directly after a medical incident because of the lack of health care support in the industry. What’s most evident about the featured childcare workers in the documentary is how much they love their work despite its challenges. Patricia in San Jose says, “I’m working 16 hours a day and Saturdays. It’s exhausting. But I love it. I love this torture. I love it. I love it.” Anne in Berkeley calls their work “a sacred responsibility.” Their frustration is not with the parents or students but with a society that has created this “broken system.” They know the importance of childcare in a functioning society that supports economics and innovation. Their fight is for proper compensation for this vital service to society. The most obvious weakness of the film is its focus on one state and the benefits of improving the childcare industry through unionization. The mechanism of unionization will not apply to the thousands of preschool employees in right-to-work states. Even in union-friendly states like California, most preschool teachers do not belong to unions and are mostly isolated from others in the field. In addition, the documentary does not provide exploration of a counterargument. Material associated with the documentary calls the film “A Love Letter to Early Educators and a Rallying Cry for a Child Care System in Crisis,” indicating the bias of the storytelling. The storytellers do not explore the reasoning behind the current structure of the childcare system. The film concludes with a call to action, directing the audience to the website where advocacy and organizing tools are provided. The audience is left to speculate reasons for the current organization of the industry without exploration of this counterargument. This film can be useful for professors and students in early childhood education or public administration programs. It is most useful as a tool to spark discussion about the importance of childcare in a functioning society and the methods for improving teaching and learning conditions. Awards:Audience Choice, Doclands Film Festival; Best Editing, United Nations Association Film Festival
Zitieren
APA
Upton, S. R. (2025). Make a Circle. Educational Media Reviews Online, 27(8). https://doi.org/10.59236/emro.v27i8a233
Vancouver
Upton SR. Make a Circle. Educational Media Reviews Online. 2025;27(8). doi:10.59236/emro.v27i8a233
BibTeX
@article{Upton2025,
author = {Upton, Summer R.},
title = {Make a Circle},
journal = {Educational Media Reviews Online},
year = {2025},
volume = {27},
number = {8},
doi = {10.59236/emro.v27i8a233}
}
EUVIMED