Youth (Hard Times)
Educational Media Reviews Online · 12.08.2025 · 27 (8)
DOI: 10.59236/emro.v27i8a210 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Educational Media Reviews Online, online erschienen am 12.08.2025. Verfasst von Andy Horbal. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Distributed by Icarus Films, 32 Court St., 21st Floor, Brooklyn, NY 11201; 800-876-1710Produced by Sonia Buchman, Nicolas De La Mothe, and Hui MaoDirected by Wang Bing2024, Streaming, 226 mins Youth (Hard Times), the middle installment in a documentary trilogy directed by Wang Bing, begins and ends more or less the same way as its predecessor Youth (Spring). It starts in media res with an overhead shot of a tattooed, shirtless young man racing a young woman through the streets of what red (instead of light green like last time) titles identify as “Zhili, Zhejiang Prince, 2015.” After a cut, the handheld camera follows them into a building labeled “workshop at 57 Xisheng Road, Zhili.” Over the subsequent nearly four hours we watch them and their fellow migrant workers brag about how fast they are, complain about broken equipment, flirt, and campaign for higher wages, before the film ends by following some of them home to the provinces for Chinese New Year. Along the way a new focus emerges, though, which marks Hard Times as distinct and potentially more worthy of attention by scholars and librarians with collection development responsibilities than Spring or series capper Youth (Homecoming). One major difference is a more ominous tone. Although both Spring and Hard Times cut back and forth between daylight scenes and nighttime scenes, the latter are now dominated not by drunken hijinks but instead exchanges like one in which a young woman’s sympathy for a co-worker struggling to keep pace with her quotas gradually sours into contemptuous scolding. This plus the presence of middle-aged characters turns what was previously a college dorm room vibe into the depressingly weary sense of a 24-hour workday: “on the clock” and “off” aren’t concepts that have much meaning when you spend months at a time in far from home just to earn money for your family. Similarly, the optimism of a successful collective bargaining session has been replaced by a foreboding extended sequence depicting the wide-reaching fallout of a factory owner who flees after beating up an employee during a pay dispute, forcing the rest of his workers to sell off the sewing equipment he left behind at a fraction of what it’s worth to recoup even part of the money they’re owed. “They say migrant work is so important and has to be closely monitored, right? But in actual fact it’s completely out of control,” one worker laments. “I mean, they’re not really companies, are they? Some guy just rents a space, runs his business as he likes, no paperwork, no rules, nothing.” The biggest departure, though, is the way the filmmakers increasingly begin to insert themselves into the story. While people glancing at and talking about the camera has been a staple of this project from the start, the person behind it speaks up for the first time about an hour into Hard Times to ask someone telling a story about police abuse for additional details. This is followed by a leading question at around the halfway point which clarifies that a factory owner was guilty of wrongdoing, then a bona fide interview an hour after that with someone who was arrested and beaten-up during riots which broke out in 2011 after a tax collector kicked a pregnant woman in the stomach, causing her to miscarry. Authorities accused workers from Anhui province of instigating the violence, rounded them up indiscriminately, and abused those they imprisoned, including the speaker, who emerged from this experience deeply disillusioned: “you watch the news, they tell you every day how great China is. But after that it looks pretty different, it looks pretty dark. You have no rights! So what’s the use of having money?” In a review for this publication, Michael J. Coffta noted that the sheer length of Youth (Spring) creates problems for instructors. With an even more substantial (by 15 minutes) 227-minute runtime, Hard Times poses the same practical challenges: it can’t easily be screened in class, and most students are unlikely to be willing to invest this much of their free time watching it from start to finish. While it’s definitely true that duration is again part of the point, though, the filmmakers’ journey toward sympathizing with their subject and distinctive moments like the ones described above and in the final reel, such as a young man playing his guitar used in many of the publicity materials for this movie and a father welcoming his son home with an impressively large and dangerous-seeming fireworks display, all lend themselves more easily to selecting brief excerpts. More importantly, Youth (Hard Times) contains many of the best elements of both Spring and Homecoming, and is therefore far and away more representative of the trilogy as a whole. Even if each episode is indisputably more impactful if you first watch the films that come before it, they can all stand alone, and this is the one I’d recommend to individual viewers willing to spend four hours satisfying their curiosity, but not ten. Awards:Special Mention, Locarno Film Festival; Junior Jury Award, Locarno Film Festival; FIPRESCI Prize, Locarno Film Festival; Best Documentary, Valladolid International Film Festival
Zitieren
APA
Horbal, A. (2025). Youth (Hard Times). Educational Media Reviews Online, 27(8). https://doi.org/10.59236/emro.v27i8a210
Vancouver
Horbal A. Youth (Hard Times). Educational Media Reviews Online. 2025;27(8). doi:10.59236/emro.v27i8a210
BibTeX
@article{Horbal2025,
author = {Horbal, Andy},
title = {Youth (Hard Times)},
journal = {Educational Media Reviews Online},
year = {2025},
volume = {27},
number = {8},
doi = {10.59236/emro.v27i8a210}
}
EUVIMED