EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Open Access · CC BY 4.0

Who, If Not Us? The Fight for Democracy in Belarus

Steve Brantley

Educational Media Reviews Online · 10.12.2025 · 27 (12)

DOI: 10.59236/emro.v27i12a84 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Educational Media Reviews Online, online erschienen am 10.12.2025. Verfasst von Steve Brantley. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Distributed by epf media, 324 S. Beverly Drive, PMB 437, Beverly Hills, CA 90212; 310-839-1500Produced by Martin Roelly and Umit UludagDirected by Juliane Tutein2023, Streaming, 79 mins The documentary Who, If Not Us? The Fight for Democracy in Belarus by filmmaker Juliane Tatein presents a rich human story of persistence and courage under authoritative rule. Belarus has been controlled for over 30 years by authoritarian dictator Alexander Lukashenka. His government is widely considered to be a repressive regime with few if any checks on its domestic power. Given this context, Belarus is under many international sanctions and is almost entirely dependent on Russia for support. Belarusian elections in 2020 and parliamentary elections in 2024 were not considered free or fair by international observers, and anti-extremism laws enforced in Belarus have resulted in harsh crackdowns on political protest and demonstrations against Lukashenko with, it is estimated, thousands of Belarusians suffering inhumane treatment, imprisonment, and torture. Filmmaker Tatein documents the day-to-day lives of three women representing three generations fighting for democratic reforms, largely through their appeals to international support. The eldest of the women subjects, Nina, finds ways to use her position as a senior citizen to protest the government without suffering the harshest of treatment due to her age and physical stature. Nevertheless, she works tirelessly to bring the government’s abuses to public scrutiny and uses her voice and freedom to speak out for the release of political prisoners. Nina spends her 75th birthday demonstrating for the release of political prisoners. She is arrested and taken to a psychiatric hospital by the police. Thankfully, the Drs recognize that she is not mentally ill and release her. Were she to be determined to be mentally ill, she could have been held against her will. Over the years of her life as an activist, Nina has been fined many times by the government. As a result, her already meager pension has been garnished to pay the debt. Tatein shows us how Nina scrapes a living together from gardening and canning. Tatein’s documentary subject Tanya is the organizer of a documentary film festival in Belarus, and because of her role in disseminating “extremist information” she is subject to government persecution and potential imprisonment. Even though she is committed to resisting Lukashenko’s regime from within Belarus, she travels illegally to Ukraine to be with her husband and son in the hope that her resistance to Lukashenko’s dictatorship can continue from outside her home country. Lastly, Darya is a young expatriate living in Vilnius, Lithuania, who fled Belarus to escape a prison sentence. Her community political organizing work brings world attention to Belarusian political prisoners. During the filming of the documentary, Russia invaded Ukraine. The added world media attention to the region has had both positive and negative effects for the Belarusian activist’s work. On one hand added attention to the injustices of the Lukashenko’s repressive policies benefit the activist’s goals. At the same time, The Belarusian military supports Russia’s aggression and the activists’ countrymen are forced to fight for Russsia in Ukraine. Tatein uses occasional video clips from independent media to contextualize the largely domestic scenes that are the backdrop of her film. The narrative that emerges about the three activists depicted is one of anonymity and isolation. A possible exception is Darya who is seen spending time with friends and other youth organizing efforts. However, even Darya is operating in exile and as such has limited ability to impact the events at home. This domesticity serves as both a strength and a weakness of the documentary. Tatein wishes to underscore the power and dedication that individuals can have in resisting oppressive governments, yet the dearth of action and exposition for the duration of the documentary makes it less gripping or engaging than most visual media available to Tatein’s audience. The film is a valuable artifact attesting to the struggle of Belarusian citizens in their fight for democratic governance under severely repressive conditions. But the film leaves much to be desired from an educational standpoint. The film does not provide an adequate historical context, and it is not clear how or whether the film’s subjects have any connection to one another. It may well be the case that the women portrayed in the film are disconnected and working in relative isolation. If Tatein wants to underscore the difficulty of organizing political resistance in Belarus, the viewer is left without that evidence, and instead the impression is one of disconnected videographic stories. I can recommend this documentary with the reservation that it should be considered highly specific to the Belarusian context and it is more a human story than an educational documentary.

Zitieren

APA

Brantley, S. (2025). Who, If Not Us? The Fight for Democracy in Belarus. Educational Media Reviews Online, 27(12). https://doi.org/10.59236/emro.v27i12a84

Vancouver

Brantley S. Who, If Not Us? The Fight for Democracy in Belarus. Educational Media Reviews Online. 2025;27(12). doi:10.59236/emro.v27i12a84

BibTeX
@article{Brantley2025,
  author = {Brantley, Steve},
  title = {Who, If Not Us? The Fight for Democracy in Belarus},
  journal = {Educational Media Reviews Online},
  year = {2025},
  volume = {27},
  number = {12},
  doi = {10.59236/emro.v27i12a84}
}
Kostenlos starten →