The Captive Pulpit: State Co-Optation, Epistemic Authority, and the Structural Limits of Religious Peacebuilding in Muslim-Majority Societies
The Critical Review of Social Sciences Studies · 23.03.2026 · 4 (1) · 4753-4768
DOI: 10.59075/v1bwgv18 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift The Critical Review of Social Sciences Studies, online erschienen am 23.03.2026. Verfasst von Syed Shamil Sadr Ul Shaheed Bokhari und 1 weiteren Autor:innen. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Islam’s theological tradition carries rich resources for reconciliation. Yet the institutions through which those resources might reach congregations, namely mosques, seminaries, and official bodies of religious scholars, have been systematically absorbed by Muslim-majority states. This article argues that state co-optation produces a structural constraint on Islamic peacebuilding that better exegesis alone cannot overcome, because the problem isn’t interpretive. It’s epistemic. When the state controls who may speak from authoritative religious positions, it doesn’t merely censor particular messages; it remakes the very category of legitimate religious knowledge, producing what this article calls the “captive pulpit.” Drawing on Abdullah Saeed’s account of ulama co-optation, Saba Mahmood’s analysis of epistemic narrowing in Egypt, and Paul Ricoeur’s philosophy of manipulated memory, the article diagnoses co-optation’s effects as simultaneously political, epistemic, and mnemonic. Comparative evidence from Pakistan, Indonesia, and Egypt demonstrates that state patronage degrades rather than enhances religious institutions’ peacebuilding credibility, while counter-institutional actors run into four structural limits: scale, reach, survivability, and legibility. Durable religious contributions to peacebuilding require genuine institutional independence. Programmatic reform of captive institutions won’t do.
Zitieren
APA
Bokhari, S. S. S. U. S., & Syed, S. B. (2026). The Captive Pulpit: State Co-Optation, Epistemic Authority, and the Structural Limits of Religious Peacebuilding in Muslim-Majority Societies. The Critical Review of Social Sciences Studies, 4(1), 4753-4768. https://doi.org/10.59075/v1bwgv18
Vancouver
Bokhari SSSUS, Syed SB. The Captive Pulpit: State Co-Optation, Epistemic Authority, and the Structural Limits of Religious Peacebuilding in Muslim-Majority Societies. The Critical Review of Social Sciences Studies. 2026;4(1):4753-4768. doi:10.59075/v1bwgv18
BibTeX
@article{Bokhari2026,
author = {Bokhari, Syed Shamil Sadr Ul Shaheed and Syed, Sara Batool},
title = {The Captive Pulpit: State Co-Optation, Epistemic Authority, and the Structural Limits of Religious Peacebuilding in Muslim-Majority Societies},
journal = {The Critical Review of Social Sciences Studies},
year = {2026},
volume = {4},
number = {1},
pages = {4753--4768},
doi = {10.59075/v1bwgv18}
}
EUVIMED