Justice Without a Forum: The Online Dispute Resolution Vacuum in Pakistan's Digital Commerce and the Architecture of a Mandatory ODR Framework
The Critical Review of Social Sciences Studies · 05.03.2026 · 4 (1) · 2205-2218
DOI: 10.59075/s24hjs42 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift The Critical Review of Social Sciences Studies, online erschienen am 05.03.2026. Verfasst von Affia Jabeen und 3 weiteren Autor:innen. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
When a Pakistani consumer transacts on a cross-border e-commerce platform and suffers loss, through a fraudulent seller, a defective digital product, or a disputed automated charge, the existing dispute resolution architecture offers no practical remedy. Provincial consumer courts lack subject-matter competence over digital transactions; arbitration clauses embedded in click-wrap agreements routinely designate foreign forums; and the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act 2016 provides a criminal enforcement mechanism but no civil restitution pathway. The result is what this article terms the "Forum Vacuum": a structural condition in which the legal right to a remedy formally exists but is practically inaccessible to the overwhelming majority of Pakistan's digital consumers. This article argues that the Forum Vacuum is not merely a procedural inconvenience but a substantive failure of the rule of law, one that systematically subsidises predatory digital commerce by ensuring that low-value cross-border disputes will never reach adjudication. Through a doctrinal-comparative methodology, the article analyses Pakistan's current multi-forum landscape, civil courts, consumer courts, the Banking Mohtasib, FIA cybercrime cells, and provincial consumer councils, and demonstrates that none provides the speed, cost-efficiency, or technical competence that digital commerce disputes require. It then benchmarks this landscape against three international models: the EU's ADR Directive (2013/11/EU) and ODR Regulation (No. 524/2013); India's SMART ODR infrastructure under the Consumer Protection (E-Commerce) Rules 2020; and UNCITRAL's Technical Notes on Online Dispute Resolution (2017). The article introduces the concept of "Remedial Accessibility" as a constitutional imperative grounded in Articles 9 and 25 of Pakistan's Constitution. It proposes a mandatory, tiered ODR architecture, comprising automated negotiation, platform-hosted mediation, and a specialist Digital Commerce Tribunal, as the essential missing pillar of Pakistan's e-commerce legal infrastructure. The article concludes that consent reform and evidence reform, however well-designed, are legally incomplete without a credible enforcement forum that the ordinary digital consumer can actually reach.
Zitieren
APA
Jabeen, A., Aleem, M., Shaukat, S., & Bhatti, K. S. (2026). Justice Without a Forum: The Online Dispute Resolution Vacuum in Pakistan's Digital Commerce and the Architecture of a Mandatory ODR Framework. The Critical Review of Social Sciences Studies, 4(1), 2205-2218. https://doi.org/10.59075/s24hjs42
Vancouver
Jabeen A, Aleem M, Shaukat S, Bhatti KS. Justice Without a Forum: The Online Dispute Resolution Vacuum in Pakistan's Digital Commerce and the Architecture of a Mandatory ODR Framework. The Critical Review of Social Sciences Studies. 2026;4(1):2205-2218. doi:10.59075/s24hjs42
BibTeX
@article{Jabeen2026,
author = {Jabeen, Affia and Aleem, Maryam and Shaukat, Samra and Bhatti, Khurram Shahzad},
title = {Justice Without a Forum: The Online Dispute Resolution Vacuum in Pakistan's Digital Commerce and the Architecture of a Mandatory ODR Framework},
journal = {The Critical Review of Social Sciences Studies},
year = {2026},
volume = {4},
number = {1},
pages = {2205--2218},
doi = {10.59075/s24hjs42}
}
EUVIMED