EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Open Access · CC BY-NC 4.0

Algorithmic Forensics of the Democratic Purse: A Causal Heterogeneous Temporal Graph Neural Network with Explainable Multi-Modal Intelligence Fusion for Detecting Illicit Political Finance, Beneficial Ownership Opacity and Corporate–Electoral Capture in Hybrid Democratic Regimes

Hamza Sajjad, Dr. Muhammad Usman Malik, Dr. Zulfqar Khan

Journal of International Law & Human Rights · 17.10.2026 · 5 (8) · 174-198

DOI: 10.59075/ilhr.v5i8.326 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of International Law & Human Rights, online erschienen am 17.10.2026. Verfasst von Hamza Sajjad und 2 weiteren Autor:innen. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY-NC 4.0).

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Purpose

Hybrid democratic regimes hold competitive elections while leaving the money that finances politics weakly observable. This study builds and tests an algorithmic-forensic framework that detects jurisdictions where illicit political finance, beneficial ownership (BO) opacity and corporate–electoral capture jointly raises illicit-finance risk, with Pakistan as the focal case. Design/methodology/approach: Using a real-data cross-section of all 36 Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) 2024 hybrid regimes plus Pakistan (EIU Democracy Index, Transparency International CPI, Basel AML Index 2025, FATF grey-list status and fourth-round BO ratings, and International IDEA political-finance rules), we construct a heterogeneous temporal graph (country, rule, region and assessment-body nodes; 455 typed country–country edges) and propose a Causal Heterogeneous Temporal Graph Neural Network (C-HTGNN) that couples NOTEARS causal discovery with relation-specific message passing and a deep neural head. Explanations use exact modality-level Shapley values, relation ablation and counterfactual simulation. Results are triangulated with multiply-imputed OLS (Rubin's rules), wild and wild-cluster bootstrap, spatial autoregressive and spatial Durbin models, Lewbel heteroskedasticity-based instrumental variables, double/debiased machine learning, augmented inverse-probability weighting, quantile regression, Oster coefficient-stability bounds, Bayesian model averaging, Firth bias-reduced logit and sup-Wald structural-break tests.

Findings

BO opacity is the only variable with a fully stable causal edge to illicit-finance risk (bootstrap frequency 1.00) and its effect strengthens in the upper tail (quantile coefficient 0.58 at τ = 0.9 versus 0.22 at τ = 0.1). Corporate–electoral capture carries a posterior inclusion probability of 0.94 and a DML effect of 0.195 per standard deviation (p = 0.053), but it is not robust to clustering by region. De jure political-finance rules show no detectable association with risk. Heterogeneous message passing outperforms a flat deep network for both AML risk and BO opacity (best BO-opacity model, out-of-sample R² = 0.38), yet gradient boosting remains the most accurate AML-risk predictor in a sample this small, and FATF grey-listing is not predictable from structural indicators. Pakistan shows a significant 2023 democratic break (bootstrap p = 0.014) and ranks 16th of 37 on the fused Illicit Political Finance Risk Score. Originality/value: The study offers the first causal graph-learning framework for political-finance forensics in hybrid regimes, and reports where deep learning helps, where it does not, and why. Practical implications: Supervisors and electoral management bodies should prioritize effective BO verification over adding formal donation bans.

Zitieren

APA

Sajjad, H., Malik, D. M. U., & Khan, D. Z. (2026). Algorithmic Forensics of the Democratic Purse: A Causal Heterogeneous Temporal Graph Neural Network with Explainable Multi-Modal Intelligence Fusion for Detecting Illicit Political Finance, Beneficial Ownership Opacity and Corporate–Electoral Capture in Hybrid Democratic Regimes. Journal of International Law & Human Rights, 5(8), 174-198. https://doi.org/10.59075/ilhr.v5i8.326

Vancouver

Sajjad H, Malik DMU, Khan DZ. Algorithmic Forensics of the Democratic Purse: A Causal Heterogeneous Temporal Graph Neural Network with Explainable Multi-Modal Intelligence Fusion for Detecting Illicit Political Finance, Beneficial Ownership Opacity and Corporate–Electoral Capture in Hybrid Democratic Regimes. Journal of International Law & Human Rights. 2026;5(8):174-198. doi:10.59075/ilhr.v5i8.326

BibTeX
@article{Sajjad2026,
  author = {Sajjad, Hamza and Malik, Dr. Muhammad Usman and Khan, Dr. Zulfqar},
  title = {Algorithmic Forensics of the Democratic Purse: A Causal Heterogeneous Temporal Graph Neural Network with Explainable Multi-Modal Intelligence Fusion for Detecting Illicit Political Finance, Beneficial Ownership Opacity and Corporate–Electoral Capture in Hybrid Democratic Regimes},
  journal = {Journal of International Law & Human Rights},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {5},
  number = {8},
  pages = {174--198},
  doi = {10.59075/ilhr.v5i8.326}
}
Kostenlos starten →