Let Slip the Dogs of Drug War: Law Enforcement Canines Do Not Fall Under the “Only-Contraband” Exception
Wisconsin Law Review · 1920
DOI: 10.59015/wlr.aupm7295 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Wisconsin Law Review, 1920. Verfasst von Olivia Phelan Heiser.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
The 2018 Farm Bill removed hemp from the Schedule I list of the Controlled Substances Act. This legal change caused law enforcement agencies and courts to reanalyze assumptions made in routine investigation tactics and prior caselaw. Some law enforcement agencies still use marijuana-trained canines. Previous Supreme Court cases have held that a sniff by a law enforcement canine is a sense-enhancing technology—but not a Fourth Amendment search—because canines detect only contraband. But marijuana-trained canines cannot detect a difference between hemp and illicit marijuana. Because these canines no longer detect only contraband, the “only-contraband” exception should no longer apply. In United States v. Deluca, the Tenth Circuit held that, even in light of the 2018 Farm Bill, a law enforcement canine can still support probable cause. But Deluca did not grapple with Supreme Court precedent explaining when use of a sense-enhancing technology constitutes a search requiring probable cause. Even though the opinion was unpublished, subsequent opinions in other jurisdictions cite Deluca to conclude the question has been asked and answered. Deluca overlooks key reasoning from Supreme Court jurisprudence on canine sniffs and must be carefully analyzed to prevent it from metastasizing in other circuits. Similarly, in United States v. Plancarte, the Seventh Circuit held that a law enforcement canine sniff is not an unreasonable search. Plancarte emphasized that dog sniffs’ limited intrusiveness does not implicate a reasonable expectation of privacy. Deluca and Plancarte signal a troubling shift in the face of advancing law enforcement sense-enhancing technology.
Zitieren
APA
Heiser, O. P. (1920). Let Slip the Dogs of Drug War: Law Enforcement Canines Do Not Fall Under the “Only-Contraband” Exception. Wisconsin Law Review. https://doi.org/10.59015/wlr.aupm7295
Vancouver
Heiser OP. Let Slip the Dogs of Drug War: Law Enforcement Canines Do Not Fall Under the “Only-Contraband” Exception. Wisconsin Law Review. 1920. doi:10.59015/wlr.aupm7295
BibTeX
@article{Heiser1920,
author = {Heiser, Olivia Phelan},
title = {Let Slip the Dogs of Drug War: Law Enforcement Canines Do Not Fall Under the “Only-Contraband” Exception},
journal = {Wisconsin Law Review},
year = {1920},
doi = {10.59015/wlr.aupm7295}
}
EUVIMED