“The Northern Man and His Corporations, the Southern Man and His Slaves”: Revisiting the Conspiracy Theory of the Fourteenth Amendment
Journal of American Constitutional History · 2025
DOI: 10.59015/jach.izcd4882 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of American Constitutional History, 2025. Verfasst von Evelyn Atkinson.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
For over a hundred years, the “conspiracy theory” of the Four-teenth Amendment has haunted legal scholarship. First articulated in a seminal case involving corporate constitutional personhood, the con-spiracy theory posits that the drafters of the Fourteenth Amendment were motivated by economic interests in addition to, or even more than, the rights of Black Americans. In recent decades scholars have dismissed the conspiracy theory as “fanciful.” Yet as this article reveals, the conspiracy theory had a basis in fact: the primary drafter of the Fourteenth Amendment, John A. Bingham, undeniably had corpora-tions in mind as well as Black Americans when he included the protection of the “privileges and immunities” of citizenship in the Amendment. Reading the history of antislavery activism together with the history of corporate personhood, this article interrogates the legal and philosophical landscape of the moment in order to uncover why, for Bingham and other advocates of corporate citizenship, the rights of corporations were as deserving of protection as the rights of Black Americans. It reveals that for decades prior to the drafting of the Four-teenth Amendment, questions involving the ability of both Black persons and corporations to claim the privileges and immunities of cit-izenship in the context of interstate mobility had dominated legal and public debate, compelling courts, individuals, and communities to con-front the nature of American citizenship, federalism, and fundamental rights.
Zitieren
APA
Atkinson, E. (2025). “The Northern Man and His Corporations, the Southern Man and His Slaves”: Revisiting the Conspiracy Theory of the Fourteenth Amendment. Journal of American Constitutional History. https://doi.org/10.59015/jach.izcd4882
Vancouver
Atkinson E. “The Northern Man and His Corporations, the Southern Man and His Slaves”: Revisiting the Conspiracy Theory of the Fourteenth Amendment. Journal of American Constitutional History. 2025. doi:10.59015/jach.izcd4882
BibTeX
@article{Atkinson2025,
author = {Atkinson, Evelyn},
title = {“The Northern Man and His Corporations, the Southern Man and His Slaves”: Revisiting the Conspiracy Theory of the Fourteenth Amendment},
journal = {Journal of American Constitutional History},
year = {2025},
doi = {10.59015/jach.izcd4882}
}
EUVIMED