Impact of a Mentored Peer-Review Program on the Sponsoring Journal: Program Evaluation at Five Years
Western Journal of Emergency Medicine · 21.10.2026 · 27 (6)
DOI: 10.5811/westjem.64401 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Western Journal of Emergency Medicine, online erschienen am 21.10.2026. Verfasst von Jeffrey N Love und 6 weiteren Autor:innen. Beteiligte Einrichtung: Georgetown School of Medicine, Department of Emergency Medicine, Washington, District of Columbia. Hauptthemen laut MEDLINE: Periodicals as Topic, Mentors, Peer Review, Emergency Medicine. Der Volltext ist frei in PubMed Central verfügbar.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Introduction
The number of peer-reviewed biomedical journals has more than tripled over the past 20–25 years increasing the demand for quality peer reviewers. This demand and the lack of available formal training in peer review have resulted in a shortage of qualified peer reviewers. In response to this shortage, the Western Journal of Emergency Medicine Special Issue in Education (Special Issue) developed a formal mentored peer-review (MPR) program that provides a learning experience in peer review to educate fellows through legitimate participation while contributing to the editorial process of the journal. The latter serves as the basis of this study.
Methods
The impact of the MPR program on the Special Issue’s reviewer pool served as the primary outcome of this study. This was accomplished by tracking the number of participating fellowships and their graduates who subsequently provided independent peer reviews for the sponsoring journal. Comparisons of MPRs generated by education fellows and their fellowship directors to those generated by our nonmentored faculty reviewers served two secondary outcomes: the quality of peer reviews and time from peer review offer to submission of the requisite peer reviews.
Results
Over a period of five years, 82 fellows mentored by 43 fellowship directors submitted 147 MPRs. Of the 60 MPR graduates (35%), 21 were retained as independent peer reviewers. Based on a five-point editorial scoring scale (5 being excellent) mentored peer reviews received significantly higher editorial ratings (4.13 [SD 0.8]) than nonmentored faculty reviews (traditional reviewers) (3.33 [1.04]) and independent reviews by program graduates (3.61 [0.84]] (P < .001). We evaluated two peer-review turnaround periods. The first was the time from the initial two offers to review until two offers had been accepted. Instances where the first two offers were randomly made to MPRs were compared to offers to nonmentored faculty reviewers. The latter group took 60.2 (32.0) days compared to the MPR group, which averaged 17.2 (16.7) days (P < .001). The second interval measured the time from reviewer acceptance of the peer review until they submitted their completed review. There was no difference between the time in days between MPRs (10.4 [7.9]) and nonmentored faculty (9.4 [8.1]) in submitting reviews that had been accepted.
Conclusion
The mentored peer-review program contributed to increasing the Special Issue’s reviewer pool with reviews of higher quality. In addition, by inviting two mentored peer-reviewers initially as compared to nonmentored faculty reviewers, the time frame for obtaining two secured peer-reviewers was significantly reduced. These findings demonstrate that a formalized approach to learning peer review by partnering with academically oriented fellowships has the potential to improve the availability of peer reviewers, the quality of peer reviews, and efficiency in the editorial review process.
Schlagwörter
MeSH-Schlagwörter (MEDLINE)
Autor:innen und Institutionen
- Georgetown School of Medicine, Department of Emergency Medicine, Washington, District of Columbia.
- Ohio State University College of Medicine, Department of Emergency Medicine, Columbus, Ohio.
- David Geffen School of Medicine UCLA, Department of Emergency Medicine, Los Angeles, California.
- Wayne State University School of Medicine, Department of Emergency Medicine, Detroit, Michigan.
- Boston University Chobanian & Avedisian School of Medicine, Department of Emergency Medicine, Boston, Massachusetts.
- Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia.
Zitieren
APA
Love, J. N., Way, D. P., Coates, W. C., Messman, A. M., Merritt, C., Ander, D. S., & Ilgen, J. S. (2026). Impact of a Mentored Peer-Review Program on the Sponsoring Journal: Program Evaluation at Five Years. Western Journal of Emergency Medicine, 27(6). https://doi.org/10.5811/westjem.64401
Vancouver
Love JN, Way DP, Coates WC, Messman AM, Merritt C, Ander DS, et al. Impact of a Mentored Peer-Review Program on the Sponsoring Journal: Program Evaluation at Five Years. Western Journal of Emergency Medicine. 2026;27(6). doi:10.5811/westjem.64401
BibTeX
@article{Love2026,
author = {Love, Jeffrey N and Way, David P and Coates, Wendy C and Messman, Anne M and Merritt, Chris and Ander, Douglas S and Ilgen, Jonathan S},
title = {Impact of a Mentored Peer-Review Program on the Sponsoring Journal: Program Evaluation at Five Years},
journal = {Western Journal of Emergency Medicine},
year = {2026},
volume = {27},
number = {6},
doi = {10.5811/westjem.64401}
}
EUVIMED