The Validity of Algorithm-Based Automated State Administration Decisions in the Single Submission Online System Reviewed from Hans Kelsen's Norm Individualization Theory
Journal of Law and Regulation Governance · 20.11.2026 · 4 (11) · 251-265
DOI: 10.57185/jlarg.v4i11.209 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Law and Regulation Governance, online erschienen am 20.11.2026. Verfasst von Muhamad Fahri und 6 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Indonesia’s Online Single Submission (OSS) system has automated various aspects of risk-based business licensing, raising legal questions concerning the validity of electronically issued state administrative decisions and accountability for potential administrative errors. This study examined the legal validity of automated administrative decisions across different business licensing risk categories and analyzed the role of algorithmic decision-making through Hans Kelsen’s theory of norm individualization. The study employed doctrinal legal research, integrating statutory and conceptual approaches with grammatical and systematic interpretations of relevant legislation and an examination of legal scholarship. The findings indicated that electronic administrative documents could satisfy the legal requirement of written form, provided that their authenticity, origin, and content were verifiable. However, the validity of automated administrative decisions also depended on lawful administrative authority, procedural compliance, and conformity with substantive licensing requirements. Automated issuance was most readily justified for low-risk business activities, whereas medium-low-risk activities relied on applicants’ declarations of compliance and remained subject to subsequent administrative oversight. Medium-high-risk activities required official verification before business operations could commence, while high-risk activities required authorization from the competent administrative authority. From the perspective of Kelsen’s theory of norm individualization, algorithms functioned as instruments for applying predefined legal norms to individual administrative cases rather than as independent sources of legal authority. Consequently, the resulting administrative decisions remained legally attributable to the competent administrative agency or official. The study concluded that legally valid and accountable administrative automation required transparent decision-making criteria, auditable records of algorithmic applications, clearly established institutional responsibility, and accessible administrative remedies for challenging legally defective decisions
Zitieren
APA
Fahri, M., Ramdani, A. N., Putri, N. M., Agustini, D., Shafarianti, N. M., Fahrezzy, F. F. F., & Ridwan, A. S. (2026). The Validity of Algorithm-Based Automated State Administration Decisions in the Single Submission Online System Reviewed from Hans Kelsen's Norm Individualization Theory. Journal of Law and Regulation Governance, 4(11), 251-265. https://doi.org/10.57185/jlarg.v4i11.209
Vancouver
Fahri M, Ramdani AN, Putri NM, Agustini D, Shafarianti NM, Fahrezzy FFF, et al. The Validity of Algorithm-Based Automated State Administration Decisions in the Single Submission Online System Reviewed from Hans Kelsen's Norm Individualization Theory. Journal of Law and Regulation Governance. 2026;4(11):251-265. doi:10.57185/jlarg.v4i11.209
BibTeX
@article{Fahri2026,
author = {Fahri, Muhamad and Ramdani, Anida Najwa and Putri, Nashwa Maura and Agustini, Dini and Shafarianti, Nanda Marthalia and Fahrezzy, Ferdi Fahrezzy Ferdi and Ridwan, Agus Septima},
title = {The Validity of Algorithm-Based Automated State Administration Decisions in the Single Submission Online System Reviewed from Hans Kelsen's Norm Individualization Theory},
journal = {Journal of Law and Regulation Governance},
year = {2026},
volume = {4},
number = {11},
pages = {251--265},
doi = {10.57185/jlarg.v4i11.209}
}
EUVIMED