EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

Comparative Analysis of Narcotics Death Penalty Discretion: A Study of Indonesia and Malaysia Post-Reform

Husnabilla Husnabilla

Journal of Law and Regulation Governance · 19.11.2026 · 4 (11) · 240-250

DOI: 10.57185/jlarg.v4i11.208 ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Journal of Law and Regulation Governance, online erschienen am 19.11.2026. Verfasst von Husnabilla Husnabilla.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

Drug-related offenses pose serious threats to national security and public welfare in Southeast Asia, prompting Indonesia and Malaysia to retain capital punishment as a stringent law enforcement measure. However, international human rights standards and domestic legal reforms have increasingly pressured both countries to restrict its application, creating complex tensions among state sovereignty, drug crime prevention, and the protection of the right to life. This study comparatively examines the legal regulation and application of judicial discretion in imposing the death penalty for drug-related offenses in Indonesia and Malaysia following their respective legal reforms. It also evaluates the implications for human rights protection and crime deterrence, identifies relevant social, legal, and political factors, and synthesizes criticisms and recommendations from the existing literature. Employing normative (doctrinal) legal research with statutory, comparative, and conceptual approaches, the study examined primary legal materials, including Indonesia's Narcotics Law (Law No. 35 of 2009) and Criminal Code (Law No. 1 of 2023), as well as Malaysia's Dangerous Drugs Act 1952 and Abolition of Mandatory Death Penalty Act 2023. The findings revealed a convergence toward more restrictive applications of capital punishment, although the two countries adopted different legal mechanisms. Indonesia retained the death penalty as a special punishment under Article 67 of Law No. 1 of 2023, with Article 100 providing for a 10-year probationary period and the possibility of commutation to life imprisonment, subject to statutory conditions. Meanwhile, Malaysia abolished the mandatory death penalty and restored judicial sentencing discretion. Nevertheless, both legal frameworks continued to face challenges, including gaps in implementing regulations, sentencing disparities, procedural irregularities, and concerns regarding torture and ill-treatment. The deterrent effectiveness of capital punishment for drug-related offenses remained empirically unsubstantiated, despite the continued prevalence of illicit drug trafficking. Justifications based on maslahah (public interest or welfare), the classification of drug trafficking as an extraordinary crime, and constitutional legitimacy continued to raise questions regarding compliance with international human rights standards restricting capital punishment to the "most serious crimes." The study concluded that post-reform sentencing discretion in both countries had not fully reconciled law enforcement objectives, public protection, and respect for human rights. Further normative, institutional, and empirical improvements were therefore necessary to establish a clearer, more accountable, proportionate, and evidence-based approach to capital punishment policy.

Zitieren

APA

Husnabilla, H. (2026). Comparative Analysis of Narcotics Death Penalty Discretion: A Study of Indonesia and Malaysia Post-Reform. Journal of Law and Regulation Governance, 4(11), 240-250. https://doi.org/10.57185/jlarg.v4i11.208

Vancouver

Husnabilla H. Comparative Analysis of Narcotics Death Penalty Discretion: A Study of Indonesia and Malaysia Post-Reform. Journal of Law and Regulation Governance. 2026;4(11):240-250. doi:10.57185/jlarg.v4i11.208

BibTeX
@article{Husnabilla2026,
  author = {Husnabilla, Husnabilla},
  title = {Comparative Analysis of Narcotics Death Penalty Discretion: A Study of Indonesia and Malaysia Post-Reform},
  journal = {Journal of Law and Regulation Governance},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {4},
  number = {11},
  pages = {240--250},
  doi = {10.57185/jlarg.v4i11.208}
}
Kostenlos starten →