The Shape of Wonder: How Scientists Think, Work, and Live
Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith · 2026-06 · 78 (2) · 125-126
DOI: 10.56315/pscf6-26lightman ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith, 2026-06. Verfasst von Alan Lightman und 1 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
THE SHAPE OF WONDER: How Scientists Think, Work, and Live by Alan Lightman and Martin Rees. Pantheon, 2025. 208 pages. Hardcover; $28.00. ISBN: 9780593702024. *Ask any person on the street to describe a "scientist." You may receive a wide range of responses. One might mention traits such as intelligence and dedication. Another may imagine a serious person wearing a lab coat. Some may hold scientists in high esteem. Some may suggest a degree of distrust. Lightman and Rees want us to know that scientists are everyday people with special training in pursuit of wonder. In The Shape of Wonder, Lightman and Rees endeavor to paint a compelling and winsome picture of who becomes a scientist, how a scientist works, and what their role in public policy and society may be. *The authors are ideally suited for this task as distinguished scholars and ambassadors for the sciences. Alan Lightman is an astrophysicist and currently MIT professor of the Practice of the Humanities. Martin Rees is the former director of the Institute of Astronomy, Master of Trinity College, Cambridge, and co-founder of the Centre for Study of Existential Risks. Both men are passionate about science and those who practice it. *The authors seek to shape how the public sees scientists and their discipline. After debates about policy measures to fight covid and climate change, some groups may be losing trust in scientists and science as whole. Lightman and Rees aim to humanize scientists and dispel myths about what science is and how it is pursued. They define the work of science as "disciplined wonder" and view scientists as ordinary people with extraordinary education. To illustrate this, the authors fill the book with winsome portraits of contemporary and historical scientists in a diversity of fields. One reads not only of these individuals' scientific pursuits, but also of their childhood, hobbies, relationships, and dreams. *The work is structured in eight chapters that explore common questions about the life of a scientist, from why they enter discipline, to how they pursue their craft, to what keeps them going. The book concludes with a discussion of scientists and ethics with respect to their role in public policy debates of our time. *Lightman and Rees are at their best describing the lives of scientists. Reading about these individuals' hopes, dreams, struggles, and even their failings, connects us with these scientists. In addition to numerous historical biographies, Lightman and Rees interviewed five currently active scientists from a wide variety of backgrounds. Often writing in the manner of a travelogue, our duo describe the experience of meeting with their fellow practitioners. At times, readers feel as if they are at tea, listening in on conversations. We see real people. One physicist confesses, "Physics is not the most fun thing I do ... sometimes it is very frustrating" (p. 79), before sharing a love of rock climbing. Another featured scientist was inspired in her pursuits by growing up in a disadvantaged community and now researches topics that could help her neighborhood. The authors capture their subjects' "humanness" well, and illustrate that the practice of "disciplined wonder" is open to anyone. *The Shape of Wonder would be a wonderful gift for scientifically inclined students and mentees or someone considering a career in science. It offers a warm introduction to the life and practice of science. However, the book does have its weaknesses. The authors missed an opportunity to explore scientists motivated by faith. They briefly mention physicist Don Page's work in speculative cosmology and casually note that he "retained his fundamentalist beliefs" (p. 95). From the context, the authors seem to be perplexed by an evangelical Christian in physics. I was disappointed that they chose not to interview Page or another scientist from a faith background since "wonder" is an integral part of Christian faith and practice. Such a discussion could have further broadened not only the discussion of wonder in the book, but also the audience for it. *The weakest section was their discussion of ethics and public policy. Lightman and Rees were motivated to write because they perceive a growing distrust of scientific opinion in debates on the environment and public health. Public trust is essential in grappling with the complicated challenges we face in public policy. We need reliable and trusted voices to provide their expertise. At this point, the authors attempt to grapple with the possibility that scientific findings can lead to both good and evil results. They confess that "sometimes it is not easy to define the good" (p. 166). They go on to state, "Our view is that science and the technology resulting from science do not have values in themselves. It is we human beings who possess values. And we should employ those values in how we use science and technology" (pp. 166-67). They conclude that good "probably meant ... increasing the well-being-happiness, and quality of life of the largest number of people ... and bad diminishes that well-being" (p. 167). *Utilitarianism is speciously attractive as a scientific approach to ethics since it advocates the collection of data and weighing the consequences. This approach can have significant unintended social results since "the greatest number" still leaves a vulnerable minority. The utilitarian view begs the question of what is "good." The authors should consider a broader exploration of ethics for applying scientific knowledge in public affairs. Public Administration scholar James Svara, for example, suggests employing multiple theories as an "Ethical Triangle" that examines policy from the perspectives of "Principles, Consequences, Virtue, and Duty"( p. 82).1 By examining policy from multiple ethical perspectives, one is forced to ponder that a policy that seems to benefit the majority may not be "good" for all in society. *While the authors approach this work from materialist convictions, the concept of wonder is implicitly Christian. Sometimes it seems that the chasm between the materialist and Christian worldview is too wide to cross. Yet we share a sense of wonder about the world and universe in which we live. As the Psalmist writes, "the heavens declare the glory of God" (Ps. 19:1). When the marvels of the creation fill us with awe, one might just discover that wonder reveals the God-shaped hole in our hearts. *Note *1James Svara, The Ethics Primer for Public Administrators in Government and Nonprofit Organizations. 2nd ed. (Jones & Bartlett Learning, 2015). *Reviewed by M. G. Moland, dean of education, arts and sciences, LeTourneau University, Longview, TX 75602.
Zitieren
APA
Lightman, A., & Rees, M. (2026). The Shape of Wonder: How Scientists Think, Work, and Live. Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith, 78(2), 125-126. https://doi.org/10.56315/pscf6-26lightman
Vancouver
Lightman A, Rees M. The Shape of Wonder: How Scientists Think, Work, and Live. Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith. 2026;78(2):125-126. doi:10.56315/pscf6-26lightman
BibTeX
@article{Lightman2026,
author = {Lightman, Alan and Rees, Martin},
title = {The Shape of Wonder: How Scientists Think, Work, and Live},
journal = {Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith},
year = {2026},
volume = {78},
number = {2},
pages = {125--126},
doi = {10.56315/pscf6-26lightman}
}
EUVIMED