EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

Christianity and Intellectual Inquiry: Thinking as Pilgrimage

Douglas Jacobsen, Rhonda Hustedt Jacobsen

Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith · 2026-06 · 78 (2) · 123-125

DOI: 10.56315/pscf6-26jacobsen ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith, 2026-06. Verfasst von Douglas Jacobsen und 1 weiteren Autor:innen.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

CHRISTIANITY AND INTELLECTUAL INQUIRY: Thinking as Pilgrimage by Douglas Jacobsen and Rhonda Hustedt Jacobsen. Oxford University Press, 2025. 221 pages. Hardcover; $29.99. ISBN: 9780197820346. *Douglas Jacobsen and Rhonda Hustedt Jacobsen's new book arises out of their long-term Religion in the Academy Project, which examines connections between higher education and religion. While their previous work, No Longer Invisible: Religion in University Education (Oxford University Press, 2012), describes the range of expressions of religion on American campuses, this one focuses on the process of intellectual inquiry at the individual level. Christianity and Intellectual Inquiry addresses the loss of Christian cultural clout in the West, particularly in the US, and notes the increasing recognition of the importance of cultural and religious contexts and how these limit our understanding. Jacobsen and Hustedt Jacobsen offer the metaphor of pilgrimage as an alternative paradigm to traditional faith and learning perspectives in Christian higher education. *The authors, with their combined backgrounds in religious history and American higher education, attempt to cover a breadth of topics: the history of the church, the history of higher education, biblical interpretations, and the American rise of identity politics. Their effort to synthesize across these topics is a strength of the book, but also a weakness that makes it difficult for readers to follow its main arguments. *The first section of Christianity and Intellectual Inquiry centers on the history of Christian traditions of faith and learning, and the second on the American social context and its faith and learning traditions. The third section attempts to build a view of faith and learning that remains available to everyone, tied to the contemporary emphasis on individual identity, and arguing for a model of pilgrimage as exemplified by four identified pathways: attentiveness, contemplation, proclamation, and compassion. Each pathway includes a representative individual along with an exploration of the pathway's ties to biblical texts and its expressions over the history of American higher education. *The first section showcases the book's strength through its contribution to a reader's understanding of the landscape of faith and learning, grounding it historically in Roman and Persian cultures and across Christian traditions up to the present. This survey connects faith and learning frameworks to the development of creeds; it provides a historical review of traditions in a range of higher educational institutions in the United States. *I found the differentiation of Catholic, Protestant, Orthodox, and Pentecostal approaches to be helpful in contextualizing and broadening our understanding of various traditions. For example, the presentation of Orthodox views of faith and learning explains the worldview of the eastern church, which sees God present everywhere and in everything; thus, secular and sacred intertwine: "they consider learning to have a sacred character because reality itself is sacred" (p. 32). *The second section of the book moves into the social history of the US and the modernist and fundamentalist debate that PSCF readers should find familiar, as will readers who have followed the history of Christian higher education. The authors draw on higher education scholars such as George Marsden, and on scientific accounts by ASA Fellow Edward Davis. The survey sets up the discussion over the present era of cognitive pluralism, which made its way into US higher education in the late twentieth century. In this framework, participants see varying perspectives as different but correct ways of seeing reality. The authors state: "Cognitive pluralism maintains that people see reality from a particular point of view derived from the thinking of the racial and ethnic communities to which they belong" (p. 71). *The authors tie cognitive pluralism to two perspectives of intellectual engagement. First, identity-constrained thinking addresses ideas based solely on their previous alignment with personal identity and personal experience. This perspective stands in contrast to a second approach of identity-informed thinking in which one's personal identity forms the ground from which to explore new ideas. Identity-constrained thinking remains closely aligned with a type of tribalism, whereas identity-informed thinking encourages engaging with others who are different. The distinction aligns with David Livingstone's work on place and science (e.g., Dealing with Darwin, 2014). Livingstone describes the richness of "trading zones," whereby different cultures engaged in a way that encouraged crossover between science and theology, in contrast to "flashpoints," whereby anxiety over science and theology led to a more tribal response. *Identity-formed thinking translates into the concept of pilgrimage--gaining interest within the Christian community--that broadens the audience to include all those who are seeking to learn something new about themselves and the world around them. Intellectual pilgrimage is thus a form of a faith and thinking process, experienced in all aspects of life. The authors construct four pathways of inquiry within this framework and use one individual as an exemplar for each: Biologist Rachel Carson serves as an exemplar of attentiveness, or empirical observation; Catholic monk Thomas Merton provides an example of contemplative thinking; Black theologian James Cone illustrates proclamation thinking; and physician Paul Farmer represents compassion thinking. *I was disappointed in this latter half of the book. First, in constructing a perspective of intellectual pilgrimage, the authors' emphasis on individual pilgrimage failed to adequately address how all thinking and knowing remain grounded in communities and traditions, whether science or faith. Thus, the intentional focus on individual pilgrimage leaves the grounding of our personhood weak and unaccounted for. Scientists, for example, work out of a communal understanding of the scientific process, a central tradition informing the exploration of reality. *Second, I found the distinctions among the four pathways to be weak, and, at times, the biblical texts used to argue for the four felt forced and artificial. Rachel Carson lived as an empirical scientist but surely her work involved proclamation and changed the trajectory of environmental understanding and policy. She also expressed deep compassion for the natural world. Paul Farmer operated out of a deep compassion for the health of the underserved but measured his effectiveness using evidence-based practice. His work remained embedded in attentiveness to local systems and cultures. James Cone spoke against structural racism, but the evidence for such broken systems is seen in empirical measurements, including the results of redlining by banks and the pattern of toxic waste facilities concentrated in communities of color. Thomas Merton's representation of contemplation seemed to represent a different type of truth seeking based on self-understanding, rather than seeking understanding about the world around us. *The authors could develop a stronger pilgrimage framework by combining the four pathways into impulses embodied by all on the journey of faith and learning. Henri Nouwen, in The Wounded Healer (1972), says that we must first articulate the truth of the pain and suffering in the world and its complex reality. Second, we must be transformed by stories of real people, places, and processes because they are concrete examples of the present state of reality. We must be attentive while we crunch numbers in order to explore the fullness of reality. Third, we should allow our emotional assessment of the situation to be transformed into intellectual understanding. Through our transformation, we may develop a deeper understanding of the societal structures around us and thus have a clearer view on what changes we wish to proclaim. Nouwen concludes that, ultimately, this process of discovery moves us toward a deeper sense of our own self-understanding in God's world. *I would recommend this book to readers for two reasons. First, its breadth adds to what many have experienced as a largely North American conversation about faith and learning. Second, the concept of pilgrimage is a rich one which invites reflection. This lens for viewing faith and learning is one that speaks to the present generation and counterbalances the traditional propositional approach to such discussions. *Reviewed by Janel Curry, president of the American Scientific Affiliation, former dean for research and scholarship at Calvin University and former provost at Gordon College.

Zitieren

APA

Jacobsen, D., & Jacobsen, R. H. (2026). Christianity and Intellectual Inquiry: Thinking as Pilgrimage. Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith, 78(2), 123-125. https://doi.org/10.56315/pscf6-26jacobsen

Vancouver

Jacobsen D, Jacobsen RH. Christianity and Intellectual Inquiry: Thinking as Pilgrimage. Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith. 2026;78(2):123-125. doi:10.56315/pscf6-26jacobsen

BibTeX
@article{Jacobsen2026,
  author = {Jacobsen, Douglas and Jacobsen, Rhonda Hustedt},
  title = {Christianity and Intellectual Inquiry: Thinking as Pilgrimage},
  journal = {Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {78},
  number = {2},
  pages = {123--125},
  doi = {10.56315/pscf6-26jacobsen}
}
Kostenlos starten →