EUVIMEDEUVIMED entdecken
Crossref

Designer Science: A History of Intelligent Design in America

C. W. Howell

Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith · 2026-06 · 78 (2) · 126-128

DOI: 10.56315/pscf6-26howell ↗

Kurz gefasst

Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith, 2026-06. Verfasst von C. W. Howell.

AbstractBibliografische AngabenZitierenVerwandte Studien

Abstract (Originalsprache)

DESIGNER SCIENCE: A History of Intelligent Design in America by C. W. Howell. NYU Press, 2025. 296 pages. Hardcover; $35.00. ISBN: 9781479827671. *"Intelligent design" (ID) has been debated in the pages of this journal for decades, but Designer Science provides something unique: a long-form history of the century-long debate around this specific term. In this book, religion scholar C. W. Howell describes not the arguments themselves, but the intellectual, social, and legal dynamics around them. It provides a valuable resource for anyone who has participated in these debates, giving a historical perspective that individual journal articles cannot, although the author's own beliefs skew the narrative somewhat. *Howell writes his history as a tale of two trials: the 1925 Scopes "Monkey Trial" and the 2005 case, Kitzmiller v. Dover. Both were local proceedings that drew national attention, both were about education more than about science, and both were more important for their social impact than for their legal findings. Also, both split Christians, some moving away from a literal interpretation of Genesis, others toward it. Chapter 1 ("The Creationists") traces the Christians before ID who were more literal interpreters of Genesis, and who split from other Christians after Scopes. Howell provides a fascinating history of the specific intellectual evolution of ID-specific ideas and terms in the 1980s. *Chapter 2 ("Design") tracks the emergence of ID as a distinct, titled movement, positioned as an alternative to both young-earth creationism and atheistic scientific naturalism. The literalism of the ID movement is not a young-earth timespan of seven 24-hour days, but Howell argues it is a literalism nonetheless. To Howell, ID's literalism is one in which living things are literally collections of machines, with the limitations as well as the advantages of machines. As an example of this, one ID proponent, Michael Behe, is quoted as saying that proteins like bacterial flagella are "literal machines" (p. 75). Behe argues that because machines cannot evolve and must be designed, then flagellar proteins must also have been designed. As a result, even ID arguments like Behe's take a mechanical form--a form that accepts many of the implicit, mechanical assumptions of atheistic naturalism. *Howell describes how ID's way of looking at science unfolded in the wider world in chapter 3 ("Politics"). Most prominently, ID proponents are associated with a politically conservative think tank, the Discovery Institute. In the 1990s, the political coalition brought together by the movement was broad and growing, but also fragile. Howell writes that "ID's nebulous nature made it popular and flexible; it also ... made it vulnerable" (p. 118). *Chapter 4 ("Backlash") describes the second of the two trials, Kitzmiller v. Dover, which Howell describes as a defeat for the ID movement. Some ID proponents contest this, because associates of the Discovery Institute did not lead the suit, and some were discarded by the legal team or withdrew before testifying, with the most prominent exception being Michael Behe. Howell argues that the legal arguments were disorganized as a result. Under scrutiny, claims that ID was a scientific theory without religious content fell apart, including statements Behe made on the stand. *In Howell's telling, this second trial is critical. Dover's legal rejection of ID arguments shifted the entire discussion away from the courts and toward discussion among Christians and atheists. An argumentative triangle developed among ID proponents, theistic evolution proponents, and the New Atheists. Howell believes the biggest split was among Christians, because the New Atheists shared some modernist assumptions with ID proponents. The rivalry between fellow Christians led to a hardening of the rhetoric from ID supporters. Howell proposes that "intelligent design continued to operate primarily as an offensively minded movement that was never able to make its disparate positions fully cohere" (p. 155). Material published in the 2010s "doubled down" on the previous arguments, and the center did not hold. *Chapters 3 and 4 are where Howell's own views (which he discloses at the beginning of the book) influence the historical account most. Howell himself is not a skeptic of the scientific consensus on evolution, which colors how he describes these conflicts. Instead, he is skeptical of the ID movement's own skepticism, and he defends the scientific consensus. Therefore, he magnifies the effect of Dover more than an ID proponent would. *Howell's position also influences his argument as he considers the legacy of ID in chapter 5 ("Aftermath"). Here he concludes that ID proponents' tendency to question the scientific consensus led to skepticism about vaccines and climate change, with negative effects. Yet he sees positive effects of this same skepticism, as it led to the Discovery Institute's Walter Bradley Center for Natural and Artificial Intelligence, established in 2018, years before AI usage became the challenge it is today. Howell sees a future in moving from machine-like conceptions of nature toward skeptical assessment of what machine-like conceptions can and should do, developing a nuanced, Christian approach to machine learning and other aspects of AI. *Designer Science is not for those considering ID arguments themselves, but for those who want to know one scholar's view of the long-term social and political context of the argument. Howell deliberately spends more time describing political and legal arguments than scientific ones and does an excellent job of this. His book is not just about tracing the creationist roots of ID arguments, but also the fruits of decades of skepticism of scientific consensus regarding evolution, both good and bad. *Overall, I think Howell maintains proper objectivity toward his subject despite his stated disagreement with the ID proponents he describes. Certainly, this book provides an opportunity for moving forward from the deadlocked rivalry between ID proponents and Christians who accept the broad outlines of evolutionary theory. In particular, the 21st-century questions concerning artificial intelligence might unite Christians who disagree over the 20th-century controversies about evolution. Howell's history offers directions by which we might grow together in our dissent from overly mechanical worldviews. *In summary, this book can be compared to Ronald Numbers's history The Creationists, but for the ID movement rather than young-earth creationists. It is not as detailed as the history provided by Numbers, being half the length. However, Designer Science is more focused on the ID movement than the young-earth creationism movement, and it includes 21st-century developments such as the Discovery Institute's Walter Bradley Center. This gives me hope. Howell speaks from his own specific perspective about the history of the 20th century and, for the most part, models an objective stance for moving into the 21st century, with opportunities for former rivals to join together in the scientific activity of constantly questioning, evaluating the evidence, and seeking truth. *Reviewed by Benjamin J. McFarland, professor of biochemistry, Seattle Pacific University, Seattle, WA 98119.

Zitieren

APA

Howell, C. W. (2026). Designer Science: A History of Intelligent Design in America. Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith, 78(2), 126-128. https://doi.org/10.56315/pscf6-26howell

Vancouver

Howell CW. Designer Science: A History of Intelligent Design in America. Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith. 2026;78(2):126-128. doi:10.56315/pscf6-26howell

BibTeX
@article{Howell2026,
  author = {Howell, C. W.},
  title = {Designer Science: A History of Intelligent Design in America},
  journal = {Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith},
  year = {2026},
  volume = {78},
  number = {2},
  pages = {126--128},
  doi = {10.56315/pscf6-26howell}
}
Kostenlos starten →