God, Pandemics, and the Holocaust
Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith · 2026-06 · 78 (2) · 134-135
DOI: 10.56315/pscf6-26cain ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith, 2026-06. Verfasst von Clifford Chalmers Cain.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
GOD, PANDEMICS, AND THE HOLOCAUST by Clifford Chalmers Cain. Wipf & Stock, 2025. 125 pages. Paperback; $23.00. ISBN: 9798385222896. *No one is immune to the question of suffering. It is perhaps the oldest question in the book: we wrestle with suffering in the creation stories of Genesis and find the struggle ubiquitous amid the visions of Revelation. We remain tempted to think that modern life possesses a unique claim to mass suffering, with the advent of mass communication and rate of information across the globe. A violent death in Cape Town can be livestreamed to New York City, a shooting of a protestor in Minnesota can be protested in Denmark by the next day. Throughout these accounts of suffering the question of God remains ever-present. Why? Why the child? Why the innocent? Why the intensity? Why the diagnosis? These questions reveal the one thing that, as humans, we both share intimately and find difficult to discuss. *Into this deep well of theological wisdom wades Clifford Chalmers Cain--holder of doctorates in both science and religion, professor emeritus at Westminster College of Missouri, theologian-in-residence at First Presbyterian Church (Greenwood, SC), and clergyman--who deftly stakes his footing early in the short volume. The book is written in a post-covid society where mass suffering marked nearly every global community. No one emerged unscathed from the pandemic, and plenty came away with more urgent theological questions. People that may have accepted personal injuries as a part of God's plan still found it difficult to justify the vast expanse of suffering and death in light of an omnipotent, benevolent God. *To address such questions in his short volume, Cain retells theological narratives of four significant times of mass suffering and death: the Bubonic plague, the Spanish flu, the COVID-19 pandemic, and the Holocaust. In each chapter, he discusses how different religious figures interpreted such experiences of suffering. In each historical event, readers can find people that blamed the suffering on the actions of humanity, and in each event, other interpreters appear determined to fit the suffering into God's greater plan. *This pattern holds until Cain's discussion of the Holocaust, where few interpreters can fathom the depth of suffering (p. 63ff). He points to Elie Wiesel's reflections on anger amid belief: "I never divorced God. It is because I believed in God that I was angry with God, and still am ... Whatever I say, it's always from inside faith" (p. 66). Cain moves from this observation to Charles Darwin's account of the brutality of nature, arguing that Darwin's move from a formal faith into a loose deism occurred due to there being "no other viable theological model to which to turn" (p. 78). *After these--at times harrowing--accounts, Cain embarks on an extended discussion of what he considers to be a more suitable philosophical and theological response to suffering (chap. 6). He generally follows the arguments of theologian Thomas Jay Oord, walking the reader through various theological approaches to the question of divine action and suffering, settling on the ways in which a deeper understanding of love can not only define God's person, but also help us to define the ways in which God is present and powerful (or not) in the world. *Throughout the text, Cain does an admirable job of dealing with a challenging and ever-present conflict. Indeed, in the tradition of process theology from which Cain writes, the question of suffering contributes both a driving and a troubling factor. Since process theology appears well suited to critically engage modern science, some interpreters in this tradition employ an evolutionary approach to human and nonhuman suffering, leaning into the co-created and co-evolutionary nature of the world. Such approaches tend to minimize the suffering of the present for the promises of the future, linking temporal perfection with divine perfection, the challenge of "suffering on the way." For example, people born with disabilities can be too easily cast off as biological and theological imperfections, and questions of eugenics--the intentional selection of healthier and smarter people over others--can too easily be supported. If theological growth is linked to time and biology, then suffering often becomes a bump in the road to perfection. *However, following tightly in Oord's and fellow theologian Catherine Keller's footsteps, Cain does not fall victim to the same mistake; instead, he faces the question of suffering head-on. He does not offer a new theological argument, but the writing provides a well-argued and well-contextualized treatment in our postpandemic global situation. Even if the reader does not necessarily subscribe to Cain's theological approach by the end of the book, all readers can appreciate the clarity of thought and the straightforward approach to challenging and controversial questions. *When it comes to deep theological questions for scientists and ministers, there remains no shortage of answers. However, a book that addresses a modern context, while presenting clear arguments, is always a welcome find. I recommend the book to all who wish to study the question of suffering and the nature of God in this postpandemic world. *Reviewed by John P. Slattery, PhD, executive director, Carl G. Grefenstette Center for Ethics in Science, Technology, and Law, Duquesne University.
Zitieren
APA
Cain, C. C. (2026). God, Pandemics, and the Holocaust. Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith, 78(2), 134-135. https://doi.org/10.56315/pscf6-26cain
Vancouver
Cain CC. God, Pandemics, and the Holocaust. Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith. 2026;78(2):134-135. doi:10.56315/pscf6-26cain
BibTeX
@article{Cain2026,
author = {Cain, Clifford Chalmers},
title = {God, Pandemics, and the Holocaust},
journal = {Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith},
year = {2026},
volume = {78},
number = {2},
pages = {134--135},
doi = {10.56315/pscf6-26cain}
}
EUVIMED