Discussion of “Automatic Numerical Analysis for Efficient and Sustainable Geotechnical Design: Insights from Real-World Applications”
Australian Geomechanics Journal · 01.12.2026 · 61 (4) · 163-164
DOI: 10.56295/agj61410 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Australian Geomechanics Journal, erschienen am 01.12.2026. Verfasst von Stephen Buttling.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This paper presents a discussion of “Automatic numerical analysis for efficient and sustainable geotechnical design: insights from real-world applications” by Ali Parsa-Pajouh and Warantorn Korkitsuntornsan. The paper makes a useful contribution to a subject which will be of interest to many upcoming geotechnical engineers. There is a very strong tendency today to be distracted by the latest developments and buzzwords, such as digital twins, workflows, scalability and sustainability, unfortunately often missing the fundamental engineering understanding which soil mechanics still requires. I accept that there are numerous references to the ongoing need for engineering judgement and evaluation, but there is clear evidence of a lack of these within the paper. I will state straight away that I am not against this type of progress, and have myself used Python Scripting to automate the running of multiple PLAXIS analyses, with substantial success. I have also used GenerativeAI to write Python Script to carry out mathematical analysis for which I already knew the answers, and was surprised when the AI falsely claimed to have succeeded. In addition I used GenerativeAI to check if it understood the geotechnical meaning of drained and saturated, which it did not. I am therefore cautious.
Zitieren
APA
Buttling, S. (2026). Discussion of “Automatic Numerical Analysis for Efficient and Sustainable Geotechnical Design: Insights from Real-World Applications”. Australian Geomechanics Journal, 61(4), 163-164. https://doi.org/10.56295/agj61410
Vancouver
Buttling S. Discussion of “Automatic Numerical Analysis for Efficient and Sustainable Geotechnical Design: Insights from Real-World Applications”. Australian Geomechanics Journal. 2026;61(4):163-164. doi:10.56295/agj61410
BibTeX
@article{Buttling2026,
author = {Buttling, Stephen},
title = {Discussion of “Automatic Numerical Analysis for Efficient and Sustainable Geotechnical Design: Insights from Real-World Applications”},
journal = {Australian Geomechanics Journal},
year = {2026},
volume = {61},
number = {4},
pages = {163--164},
doi = {10.56295/agj61410}
}
EUVIMED