DELIBERATIVE DEMOCRACY: A RHETORICAL CRITIQUE
ARACÊ · 14.05.2026 · 8 (5) · e13118
DOI: 10.56238/arev8n5-058 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift ARACÊ, online erschienen am 14.05.2026. Verfasst von Roberto Wagner Mendonça und 1 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
This article examines deliberative democracy as a contemporary attempt to reconstruct the legitimacy of the rule of law under conditions of normative pluralism and institutional complexity. While deliberative theory presents itself as a response to the erosion of legal authority, grounding legitimacy in public justification and discursive procedures, the article argues that this reconstruction rests on demanding and often unrealistic communicative, epistemic, and social assumptions. Drawing on a rhetorical perspective, classical theories of persuasion, the linguistic turn, and the notion of dissoi logoi, the analysis challenges the deliberative claim that political legitimacy can emerge from rational consensus independent of power relations and rhetorical inequality. The article shows that deliberative practices do not neutralize discretion or domination, but rather redistribute them through institutionally authorized vocabularies of justification that privilege certain speakers, forms of reasoning, and expertise. As a result, deliberative democracy risks converting legitimacy into a function of discursive competence and institutional position rather than democratic self‑rule. The final section argues that this dynamic has significant implications for the contemporary understanding of the rule of law, which increasingly operates not as a constraint on power but as a rhetorical register for legitimizing discretionary decisions ex post. The article concludes that deliberative democracy, far from overcoming the semantic hollowing‑out of the rule of law, may contribute to its consolidation.
Zitieren
APA
Mendonça, R. W., & Adeodato, J. M. (2026). DELIBERATIVE DEMOCRACY: A RHETORICAL CRITIQUE. ARACÊ, 8(5), e13118. https://doi.org/10.56238/arev8n5-058
Vancouver
Mendonça RW, Adeodato JM. DELIBERATIVE DEMOCRACY: A RHETORICAL CRITIQUE. ARACÊ. 2026;8(5):e13118. doi:10.56238/arev8n5-058
BibTeX
@article{Mendona2026,
author = {Mendonça, Roberto Wagner and Adeodato, João Maurício},
title = {DELIBERATIVE DEMOCRACY: A RHETORICAL CRITIQUE},
journal = {ARACÊ},
year = {2026},
volume = {8},
number = {5},
pages = {e13118},
doi = {10.56238/arev8n5-058}
}
EUVIMED