COMBINING ECOLOGICAL FOOTPRINT, ECOSYSTEM SERVICES, AND SDG FRAMEWORKS INSIDE TOURISM SUSTAINABILITY ASSESSMENT: A SYSTEMATIC EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS
Jurnal Darmawisata · 31.05.2026 · 5 (2)
DOI: 10.56190/jdw.v5i2.53 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Jurnal Darmawisata, online erschienen am 31.05.2026. Verfasst von Abdul Samad Hiola.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Tourism sustainability assessment increasingly draws upon three principal frameworks: Ecological Footprint accounting to quantify biophysical pressures, ecosystem services approaches to capture nature’s contributions to people, and Sustainable Development Goals indicators to benchmark progress and policy coordination. This systematic literature review integrates the application of these schemes within tourism research and delineates requirements for their inclusion into a coherent assessment architecture that is both comparable across destinations and implementable within governance contexts. The review utilizes a systematic design, incorporating transparent screening, eligibility assessment, and synthesis procedures in accordance with PRISMA principles. Studies were coded according to measurement boundary (product/destination versus national), indicator logic (pressure, benefit/dependence, outcome), and implementation orientation (governance, decision-support, uncertainty). The synthesis identifies ongoing fragmentation among frameworks. Ecological Footprint studies present robust pressure diagnostics but commonly lack the decomposition and attribution mechanisms necessary for destination-level policy, and econometric results are highly sensitive to the choice of tourism proxies (e.g., arrivals versus receipts) and national context. While Sustainable Development Goals benchmarking enhances comparability, it may conflict with natural constraints, as high benchmark scores can coincide with elevated ecological loads and development–environment trade-offs. Ecosystem services scholarship supplies essential bridging logic by highlighting social–ecological interdependencies and risk-sensitive service flows central to nature-based tourism; however, ecosystem service indicators are seldom incorporated into routine tourism reporting aligned with Sustainable Development Goals. Implementation-oriented research demonstrates that integration is achievable only when indicator systems are harmonized and embedded within governance processes through decision-support methods, participatory appraisal, and multi-horizon approaches that address climate risk and response. Overall, the review demonstrates that an integrated assessment combining Ecological Footprint, ecosystem services, and Sustainable Development Goals frameworks produces more comprehensive, policy-relevant, and comparable evaluations than single-framework approaches. The study suggests an integration-oriented synthesis pathway to cross-reference pressures, dependencies/benefits, and outcomes, and identifies future research priorities in standardized mapping, destination-scale validation, and equity-sensitive, climate-aware monitoring
Zitieren
APA
Hiola, A. S. (2026). COMBINING ECOLOGICAL FOOTPRINT, ECOSYSTEM SERVICES, AND SDG FRAMEWORKS INSIDE TOURISM SUSTAINABILITY ASSESSMENT: A SYSTEMATIC EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS. Jurnal Darmawisata, 5(2). https://doi.org/10.56190/jdw.v5i2.53
Vancouver
Hiola AS. COMBINING ECOLOGICAL FOOTPRINT, ECOSYSTEM SERVICES, AND SDG FRAMEWORKS INSIDE TOURISM SUSTAINABILITY ASSESSMENT: A SYSTEMATIC EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS. Jurnal Darmawisata. 2026;5(2). doi:10.56190/jdw.v5i2.53
BibTeX
@article{Hiola2026,
author = {Hiola, Abdul Samad},
title = {COMBINING ECOLOGICAL FOOTPRINT, ECOSYSTEM SERVICES, AND SDG FRAMEWORKS INSIDE TOURISM SUSTAINABILITY ASSESSMENT: A SYSTEMATIC EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS},
journal = {Jurnal Darmawisata},
year = {2026},
volume = {5},
number = {2},
doi = {10.56190/jdw.v5i2.53}
}
EUVIMED