Formal Harmonisation, Informal Divergence: Administrative Culture in European Public Procurement
Business & Management Compass · 2025
DOI: 10.56065/kq2wma16 ↗Kurz gefasst
Fachartikel in der Zeitschrift Business & Management Compass, 2025. Verfasst von Ehsan Hatamian. Der Volltext ist frei zugänglich (Open Access, CC BY 4.0).
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Purpose
This study investigates whether three decades of EU procurement harmonisation have created unified administrative practices or whether document-observable patterns persist, demonstrating proof-of-concept for transforming procurement documents into strategic intelligence addressing cross-border B2B information asymmetry. Design/Methodology/Approach: This study analyses 2,370 software packages and information systems public procurement notices (CPV 48000000) from 17 European countries (2023-2024) using an automated Cultural Intelligence Extraction System (CIES), achieving 95.4% expert validation accuracy. One hundred one parameters across twelve dimensions are extracted. ANOVA with effect-size prioritisation (η²) and hierarchical multi-level clustering are employed.
Findings
Document-observable patterns demonstrate extreme variation despite harmonisation: 8.8× verbosity range, 10.1× technical specification range, 5.6× scope range, with country explaining 50% of transparency variance (η² = 0.500). Multi-level clustering identifies five procurement strategies: Extreme Verbosity (Hungary), Multi-Domain Integration (Romania), Efficient Minimalism (a cross-regional cluster of Czech, Finland, and Switzerland), Western/Nordic Mainstream (comprising nine countries), and Eastern/Southern Moderate Complexity (Bulgaria, Greece, and Poland). Economic analysis reveals a multi-lot value paradox: 20% of tenders capture 72% of contract value, with a 294-fold variation in value concentration. Research Implications: The results validate the institutional theory's formal/informal distinction: EU directives harmonise legal procedures, while administrative practices diverge. Findings enable a document-to-intelligence transformation, providing suppliers with market selection guidance, authorities with efficiency benchmarking, and policymakers with frameworks to distinguish harmonizable dimensions from legitimate diversity. Originality/Value: Large-scale automated administrative pattern extraction demonstrating systematic document-to-intelligence transformation for B2B strategic positioning. A hybrid LLM-rule-based system with anti-hallucination validation establishes a methodological blueprint for extracting procurement intelligence at scale.
Zitieren
APA
Hatamian, E. (2025). Formal Harmonisation, Informal Divergence: Administrative Culture in European Public Procurement. Business & Management Compass. https://doi.org/10.56065/kq2wma16
Vancouver
Hatamian E. Formal Harmonisation, Informal Divergence: Administrative Culture in European Public Procurement. Business & Management Compass. 2025. doi:10.56065/kq2wma16
BibTeX
@article{Hatamian2025,
author = {Hatamian, Ehsan},
title = {Formal Harmonisation, Informal Divergence: Administrative Culture in European Public Procurement},
journal = {Business & Management Compass},
year = {2025},
doi = {10.56065/kq2wma16}
}
EUVIMED