Beyond the Numbers: A Mixed-Method Evaluation of Faculty, Peer, and Self-Assessment Using Rubrics in Blood Pressure Determination among Phase 1 MBBS Students
Health Professions Education · 01.01.2026 · 12 (3)
DOI: 10.55890/2452-3011.1406 ↗Kurz gefasst
Mixed-Methods-Studie in der Zeitschrift Health Professions Education, online erschienen am 01.01.2026. Verfasst von Abeetha S und 4 weiteren Autor:innen.
Abstract (Originalsprache)
Background
Competency-Based Medical Education (CBME) emphasizes formative, learner-centred assessment. Blood pressure (BP) measurement, a core clinical skill, integrates knowledge, skills, communication, ethics, and attitude. While rubrics are widely used to standardize evaluation, their utility in triangulating faculty, peer, and self-assessment in BP measurement remains underexplored.
Aim
To evaluate the reliability and educational value of rubric-based faculty, peer, and self-assessment in BP determination among Phase 1 MBBS students using a mixed-methods approach.
Methods
A cross-sectional mixed-methods study was conducted among 98 Phase 1 MBBS students in a South Indian medical college. Forty-nine students performed BP measurement, assessed simultaneously by 5 faculty and 49 peer using a validated Knowledge, Skill, Attitude, Ethics, and Communication (KSAEC) rubric. Self-assessment was done after performing the BP Measurement using a KSAEC rubric. Quantitative data were analysed using descriptive statistics, paired comparisons, and correlation analysis. Qualitative feedback was collected via open-ended reflections and thematically analysed.
Results
The rubric demonstrated high content validity (Scale-CVI = 0.92) and good inter-rater reliability (ICC = 0.81). Self-assessment scores were consistently higher than peer and faculty scores, particularly in subjective domains such as communication, attitude, and ethics (p < 0.05). Peer assessments aligned more closely with faculty scores in objective domains, with strongest correlations for knowledge (r = 0.60–0.67). Qualitative analysis revealed themes of clarity, structured feedback, reflective learning, challenges in assessing subjective domains, and social bias.
Conclusion
Rubric-based self- and peer-assessment foster reflective learning and reinforce technical competencies in early clinical training. While self-assessment is prone to inflation, it remains valuable for metacognition when scaffolded by clear criteria. Peer assessment is a reliable, scalable alternative for formative feedback, particularly in objective domains. For subjective competencies like professionalism and communication, multimodal strategies such as Mini-CEX and multisource feedback are recommended.
Zitieren
APA
S, A., M, C., A, S., Dharani, B., & S, S. (2026). Beyond the Numbers: A Mixed-Method Evaluation of Faculty, Peer, and Self-Assessment Using Rubrics in Blood Pressure Determination among Phase 1 MBBS Students. Health Professions Education, 12(3). https://doi.org/10.55890/2452-3011.1406
Vancouver
S A, M C, A S, Dharani B, S S. Beyond the Numbers: A Mixed-Method Evaluation of Faculty, Peer, and Self-Assessment Using Rubrics in Blood Pressure Determination among Phase 1 MBBS Students. Health Professions Education. 2026;12(3). doi:10.55890/2452-3011.1406
BibTeX
@article{S2026,
author = {S, Abeetha and M, Chitra and A, Suba and Dharani, B. and S, Sadhana},
title = {Beyond the Numbers: A Mixed-Method Evaluation of Faculty, Peer, and Self-Assessment Using Rubrics in Blood Pressure Determination among Phase 1 MBBS Students},
journal = {Health Professions Education},
year = {2026},
volume = {12},
number = {3},
doi = {10.55890/2452-3011.1406}
}
EUVIMED